330Ci or G35C

[Tremulant]

G35 Coupe. My dad has one, and I drive it on the weekends :heart:.

 

[Eli]

Originally posted by: SWScorch
I'd take almost anything over a G35. Even an Aztek is better looking. (Plus, the Aztek I drove as a loaner for a week was really really nice)

:Q

 

[AzNmAnJLH]

G35c is the best looking nissan, i never really like how the R32 looked anyways

 

[bastula]

My dad has a 328i. I love that car --> Bimmer for sure

 

[Smaug]

If you really like your BMW dealerships service department and want to visit them monthly, get the bimmer.

Otherwise the G35 is far better.

 

[masterxfob]

there's no point in owning a BMW if it doesn't have at least a straight 6.

 

[Emrys]

Originally posted by: spidey07
Acura TL.

That is what I was thinking. For that money why not just get a fully loaded TL with nav system? It's not a coupe like the 330, but I'd take a look at it. If you just can't deal with 4 door, I'd take the G35c over the BMW, more car for the money.

 

[raptor13]

Originally posted by: SuperTool
I think as far as drivetrain, they are tied. As far as looks, each has it's fans so also a tie.
Interior goes to the Bimmer, but the price goes to the G35. And it just so happens that the 330i's interior is not $10K better than G35's. Additionally G35 is going to be more reliable and cheaper to maintain, since the engine is used in almost every Nissan car now, and is extremely reliable engine. It has been on ward's 10 best since it came out in 1994 on the 1995 Nissan Maxima.
So G35c is a much better car in terms of what you are getting for the money, though the 330i is slightly better car if money is no object.

Do you mean to say that BMW might have problems with the inline sixes they have been building for the past thirty some years? They know a thing or two about engines of that layout and there is a reason the 3 series and the M3 have achieved legendary status for their buttery smooth, powerful, free revving, and reliable engines, amongst other things.

Notice also that no company in the world designs a car saying, "Boys, here's the high water mark we have to beat - the Infinity!!!"

That said, the $10,000 price difference is hard to overlook. Regardless, BMW lights the fire in my heart. I am a very, very happy owner. :heart:

EDIT: I take it back. BMW built its first inline six in 1933. Good Lord I love them.

 

[bbkat]

Originally posted by: z0mb13
I own a 330ci, so guess what my answer is?

 

[sillymofo]

Originally posted by: PricklyPete

Originally posted by: SWScorch
I'd take almost anything over a G35. Even an Aztek is better looking. (Plus, the Aztek I drove as a loaner for a week was really really nice)

I question your eyesight...

Eyesight? I question his sanity.

 

[bozack]

Originally posted by: nightowl
G35 Coupe all the way. It just looks so much better than the bimmer

I know it is personal prefernce but IMHO the G35 looks like trash, not as bad without that stupid factory spoiler but still cheap looking.

 

[SuperTool]

Originally posted by: raptor13

Originally posted by: SuperTool
I think as far as drivetrain, they are tied. As far as looks, each has it's fans so also a tie.
Interior goes to the Bimmer, but the price goes to the G35. And it just so happens that the 330i's interior is not $10K better than G35's. Additionally G35 is going to be more reliable and cheaper to maintain, since the engine is used in almost every Nissan car now, and is extremely reliable engine. It has been on ward's 10 best since it came out in 1994 on the 1995 Nissan Maxima.
So G35c is a much better car in terms of what you are getting for the money, though the 330i is slightly better car if money is no object.

Do you mean to say that BMW might have problems with the inline sixes they have been building for the past thirty some years? They know a thing or two about engines of that layout and there is a reason the 3 series and the M3 have achieved legendary status for their buttery smooth, powerful, free revving, and reliable engines, amongst other things.

Notice also that no company in the world designs a car saying, "Boys, here's the high water mark we have to beat - the Infinity!!!"

That said, the $10,000 price difference is hard to overlook. Regardless, BMW lights the fire in my heart. I am a very, very happy owner. :heart:

EDIT: I take it back. BMW built its first inline six in 1933. Good Lord I love them.

Nothing wrong with the BMW inline 6's but I would pick Infiniti reliability/maintainance costs over a BMW. I can't comment on the I6 reliability, but my Maxima VQ30DE is running strong at 140K miles, with only sparkplugs and knock sensor changed.

 

[Babbles]

I think contrary to what people want to think, pricey German cars (i.e. BMW and Mercedes) are not known for long lasting reliablity. Especially so compared to the likes of Nissan.

 

[Doggiedog]

Originally posted by: SuperTool

Originally posted by: raptor13

Originally posted by: SuperTool
I think as far as drivetrain, they are tied. As far as looks, each has it's fans so also a tie.
Interior goes to the Bimmer, but the price goes to the G35. And it just so happens that the 330i's interior is not $10K better than G35's. Additionally G35 is going to be more reliable and cheaper to maintain, since the engine is used in almost every Nissan car now, and is extremely reliable engine. It has been on ward's 10 best since it came out in 1994 on the 1995 Nissan Maxima.
So G35c is a much better car in terms of what you are getting for the money, though the 330i is slightly better car if money is no object.

Do you mean to say that BMW might have problems with the inline sixes they have been building for the past thirty some years? They know a thing or two about engines of that layout and there is a reason the 3 series and the M3 have achieved legendary status for their buttery smooth, powerful, free revving, and reliable engines, amongst other things.

Notice also that no company in the world designs a car saying, "Boys, here's the high water mark we have to beat - the Infinity!!!"

That said, the $10,000 price difference is hard to overlook. Regardless, BMW lights the fire in my heart. I am a very, very happy owner. :heart:

EDIT: I take it back. BMW built its first inline six in 1933. Good Lord I love them.

Nothing wrong with the BMW inline 6's but I would pick Infiniti reliability/maintainance costs over a BMW. I can't comment on the I6 reliability, but my Maxima VQ30DE is running strong at 140K miles, with only sparkplugs and knock sensor changed.

The BMW I6 engine is supposedly very reliable. Its the rest of the car that isn't. Thus far, I haven't had any engine problems unless you count the radiator (94K)which supposedly all fail around the 100K mark on BMWs. I've had a bad AC, lights, suspension, wiper, radio and brakes.

 

[Asharus]

Originally posted by: FrustratedUser

Originally posted by: notfred
The BMW, because it's a BMW rather than a Nissan.

True. I'd take the BMW any day. Much nicer looking car with (probably) a higher resale value.

I can vouch for the higher resale value. My 92 525i is worth more than a 96 Ininity I30 w/ 30k less miles.

 

[Asharus]

Originally posted by: SuperTool

Originally posted by: Asharus

Originally posted by: SuperTool
G35 is the rebadged Japanese Nissan Skyline
It is not a rebadged Altima.

You're thinking of the G35C, plus it's still a 350Z + a backseat.

G35 has different interior, exterior, body from 350Z. They do have a common platform, such as engine, transmission, and suspension components. I don't see what the problem with that is. By your logic, Acura MDX is just an Oddysey with bigger ground clearance.
Click on that link. Both G35 sedan and G35 coupe are called Nissan Skyline in Japan.
Longitudonally mounted V6 with RWD. Altima is transversely mounted V6 FWD.
FM Platform: G35, G35C, FX35, FX45, upcoming M45
FF? platform: Altima, Quest, Murano, Maxima
Capiche?

I didn't say that it was a problem, the 350Z is a very nice car. What I'm saying is that it's based on the same chassis.

 

[Red]

I drive a '97 Infiniti I30...

BUT, having said that, I'd probably have to pick the...

G35c of course. It's a FACT that it's cheaper, faster, receives higher marks for reliability and dealer customer service. And, subjectively, it looks a helluva lot better than a 3 series BMW.

BMW can keep their resale value. In 10 years, you might 1 or 2 grand more for your BMW, but it still doesn't make up for $10,000 difference you paid in the beginning. Muahahah.

 

[Shyatic]

RX-8? Has a useable back seat, costs less than both and handles better then both too. Not as fast as the G35C but as fast as the 330Ci, and it's comfy and well made aside from a few parts.

And you'll save a bundle too.

 

[CombatChuk]

G35 I believe it's more reliable...

 

[BigSmooth]

Originally posted by: Asharus

Originally posted by: FrustratedUser

Originally posted by: notfred
The BMW, because it's a BMW rather than a Nissan.

True. I'd take the BMW any day. Much nicer looking car with (probably) a higher resale value.

I can vouch for the higher resale value. My 92 525i is worth more than a 96 Ininity I30 w/ 30k less miles.

The I30/35 was from the era when Infiniti was selling rebadged Nissans, which crippled their resale values. Infiniti's resale values have climbed very quickly in the last year or two, mainly because of the G35 (which got a 5 Star rating). However, as you can see in that first link, BMW is tops in the industry as a brand.

 

[johnjbruin]

I drive a G35S - picked it over the 330.
Since you are looking at coupes - there is no question about picking the G35C.

 

[CRXican]

Originally posted by: Scribe
RX-8? Has a useable back seat, costs less than both and handles better then both too. Not as fast as the G35C but as fast as the 330Ci, and it's comfy and well made aside from a few parts.

And you'll save a bundle too.

good joke, ha ha ha

 

[erikistired]

for me the driving experience is more important than a leather dash, and driving a bmw is one of the finer things in life. heck i'd buy another vw gti over a g35 tho, but i'm a german car whore so i guess i'm biased.

 

[Asharus]

Originally posted by: Red
I drive a '97 Infiniti I30...

BUT, having said that, I'd probably have to pick the...

G35c of course. It's a FACT that it's cheaper, faster, receives higher marks for reliability and dealer customer service. And, subjectively, it looks a helluva lot better than a 3 series BMW.

BMW can keep their resale value. In 10 years, you might 1 or 2 grand more for your BMW, but it still doesn't make up for $10,000 difference you paid in the beginning. Muahahah.

Heh, I paid $6k for my car about 2 years ago, and it's still worth the same. I don't buy new, I'm poor.

 

[hans007]

Originally posted by: fisher
for me the driving experience is more important than a leather dash, and driving a bmw is one of the finer things in life. heck i'd buy another vw gti over a g35 tho, but i'm a german car whore so i guess i'm biased.

at least you are honest.





i'm probably going to buy a g35 sedan at some point in the next year. and well, i probably couldnt afford a decent bmw that could perform like it (i figure a 330i performance package at $12000 dollars more is probably not worth it, since it still would be far less spacious).


i'd say most of the reasons for buying a bmw, are either style based, or the i can have a bmw logo on my key to show chicks at bars reason.

since well the g35 basically beats a 330 in every single performance benchmark, costs less and is roomier.