I have several questions about over-contributing to a Roth IRA. First, some background:
I'm a graduate student supported by a DOE fellowship. I do not receive a W-2; there is no automatic withholding program. Thus I have 0 "earned income" or "compensation" (i.e. box1, form W-2).
Last year, I opened a Roth IRA acct with ETrade, thinking that starting to save for retirement would be a good idea. Too bad the government disagrees. I didn't realize that I'm not allowed to hold an IRA until very recently.
Anyway I contributed 10,000 to that Roth: 5000 under the 08 limit & 5000 under the 09 limit. I invested it all in stocks/mutual funds; the acct is currently worth about 16k.
As I understand it, if I don't withdraw ALL of the money before tax-day, I will owe a 6% excise tax on 10,000.
So fine, I'll close the account. I instructed Etrade to shut it down & distribute/deposit the cash/securities to my regular trading account. But I am horribly confused on what taxes/penalties I will owe. In the account, there is:
$10.50 cash
210 shares DHT (stock)
354 shares HGSI (stock)
18.482 shares VFINX (large cap index fund: all stocks)
45.129 shares OAKBX ("equity and growth" fund: has stocks AND treasury bills)
Current value is ~16k, which includes dividends earned from the 2 funds.
It sounds like the assets will just be moved into my regular trading acct, as opposed to me having to sell & re-buy them.
So do I owe early withdrawal fee (10%) on (16000 - 10000) ?
Or do I only owe the 10% fee on the dividends from the mutual funds & the 10.50 cash? (And I'll owe 10% on the securities when/if I sell them.)
Or is it something else entirely?
I assume I also owe some income tax on the earnings from my Roth. Do I just owe on the interest for now? Will I be forced to pay capital gains taxes on the securities as well? Or will that be delayed until I actually sell the securities?
What form(s) will I need to fill out to report all of this correctly to the IRS? I think I should receive a 1099R with the distribution. I think I will need to file 8086 and 5329 too?
Another question actually: shouldn't etrade have prevented me from establishing a roth in the first place? UGhhhhhhhhhh!
Thanks guys,
-Eric
Also, f*ck you government. How is it that I have taxable income but no earned income? You don't think being a graduate student involves work? I didn't earn my fellowship? Why aren't I allowed a retirement account?! /rant