bluemax,
Bite the bullet and go for Radeon 7500 DDR (Retail). I just picked one up at Staples for $229.95 before taxes. It replaces my Voodoo 2 3000 16MB AGP. So far so good. I am not a gamer, and it is very sharp in 2D.
Running under WinXP Pro Corp
Go for it
You can get it cheaper at NCIX, but I wanted it quick.
c8