- Oct 5, 2009
- 5,034
- 2,613
- 136
Yeah this is stupid. You realize two people can be equally good. In fact one guy could be better than the other in everyway. However due to things like school prestige, school and parent funding to put together a perfect application, school internal connections and lobbying, one guy get the Harvard admission and the other guy goes to his state school. This happens at the college application level, the graduate level, even the post graduate level. Even in research grants, almost all the research grants in the US go to a small handful of colleges (the same colleges we are talking about. You're talking about grants where the applicants are the best of the best doctors and researchers and still it's mostly Harvard and Yale getting the money). You have such a huge leg up going to a handful of schools (be it high school, college, med school etc). That's why everyone wants to go there. Harvard doesnt teach different laws of physics or different rules of English grammar. Harvard's advantage upon completion of training isn't merit based (for example almost every SCOTUS in history went to Harvard or Yale. Do you really think there are no excellent judges that went to the U of Florida law school in US history?). It's mostly the accumulation of many non merit based advantages that an individual would not get elsewhere.I have no issue with merit based admissions. I also have no issue with providing supplementary training for those who have attended poor quality schools. I do have an issue with admissions being race based. I want my doctor, lawyer, accountant, and engineer to be the best. I don't care what they look like, I don't care about their skin color or sexual preference.
It's all about having faith in who's doing the job. The fellow who recently performed surgery on my testicle's got the job because of his ability, not his skin color.
The reality is there is no objective merit based system for entrance criteria. A lot of it is based on :
This guy is rich
This guy went an expensive school
This guys has connections
This guy has someone working for him to polish his application
The point is trying to pretend that being rich isn't a surrogate for being white and pretending that everyone is even in the eyes of college entrance committees or even in the world in general is stupid. Things arent even. Society so try to make them even.
Honestly states could fix all this shit by just passing laws blocking legacy admissions, requiring quotas for low income students, requiring a certain percentage of people who are the first in their family to go to college, etc etc.
Last edited: