American Idol again......

[Chello02]

they need to hurry it up with these seasons. get all the tallent out in the open then winners will all be hillariously awfull and their ratings will sore.

 

[OCNewbie]

I watched tonight's final Ep, and listened to Vonzelle singing with that dude playing the piano. I thought she had a great sound to her voice, much more enjoyable than Carrie. Also I agree that Carrie did a pretty crappy job on Martina's Independence Day last night, though I'm quite familiar with Martina's version, so it was easy to compare, and MM is hard to beat. I thought Bo would win. I thought his performance tonight with Lynark Skynard was great. Of all the performances tonight, I think his performance with Skynard brought the house down the most, by a good bit. Carrie has a good range on her vocals, but she just doesn't sound pleasant with a lot of her notes, like others have mentioned, it's just something she's missing. I'm sure they'll all sound much better once in a recording studio and some more practice on specific songs.

 

[tocoolformyself]

Originally posted by: her209

Originally posted by: jonnyGURU
Bo's going to be famous just the same. HE'S the one with talent.

And he won't be stuck with a sh!tty contract.

I think the they both get a crappy contract.

 

[RagingBITCH]

Whose going to want some Kid Rock wannabe as an AI? Seriously. As soon as it was down to two, Carrie won.

 

[Excelsior]

Originally posted by: Pacfanweb

Originally posted by: Excelsior
Goddamnit don't bring politics into OT.


And I think Vonzell was a better singer than Carrie, and she should have won.

How in the hell can anyone think Vonzell was a better singer than Carrie? Carrie can sing throughout her whole vocal range.

Vonzell can only carry a tune when she's wailing. She constantly butchered songs that started out low.

As far as the show's winner....I'd say the right person won. Bo is a better performer, but not a better singer. American Idol is a singing competition.
Bo sang the old song Vehicle again tonight, and also last night. Both times, he was worse than the first time he sang it.
Plus, he sang wimpy, sappy songs for his other two last night. That wasn't his thing, and both were totally opposite from the songs he's been singing, for the most part.

I like both singers, and both will do well. Carrie may well sell more records than Kelly, who I'm sure must be the best seller of all the Idols.
She may have been better off losing, then signing a contract with a Nashville company, at least in the short run.
We'll have to let her Idol contract play out now, and wait until a real record company and producer get ahold of her to see what she can do.

Apparently me and many other people. Were you watching the same show? It doesn't matter anyway, because when they put out a record..their voice will be altered enough to make it sound quite good.

 

[Excelsior]

Originally posted by: rh71
bottom line... who's more of an idol ? The hot chick. That's the way it should be. They named the show American Idol. It has to have some pull, ALONG with talent (or even above it).

I don't know who wants to idolize Bo, or even Ruben. Clay I can see... Kelly and Fantasia I can see... and now Carrie I can easily see.

(Yes, I'm saying this show can very much be rigged when it comes to the final few - and who has the most appeal). Someone must've been sleeping when Ruben won though...

Even Fantasia?

...

 

[Excelsior]

Originally posted by: Duvie

Originally posted by: Doboji

Originally posted by: Sphexi
And Carrie wins....dammit

yeah exactly....

BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO carrie sucks she's another example of this new world... where we worship the hot chic regardless of whether she has a brain or talent or anything else....

makes me kinda sick to my stomach frankly

-Max

Hot Chic?? Try fat chic...That girl is too thick for my liking and is as fun to watch on the stage as to listening to Michael Moore rant his conspiracy theories...

Anybody remember the comment Simon made like 8 weeks ago after she sang some song where he predicted " you will sell more records then any past idol winner"...Yeah Right!!!

Kelly rocks here...She has 3 songs in the top 40 and the album is in like the top 3 billboard charts...Simon said that as a satb against all the past idol winners who are usually more then glad to got out of their 1 year contract. Some like Clay use lawyers....

This will be a Clay/Reuben all over again... The second place finisher is going to rock the winner...She can go linger in obscurity with the once again waning country music genre...Bo is going to take off in a rival of rock.

Actually if you look at it last years suck-arse Fantasia has been outdone by Diana Degarmo who has a much more lucrative Disney contract and sold more albums I believe...

Reubens POS album tanked faster then his try at dieting!!! HAHAHAHA


Kelly is truly about the only one that has ever had talent out of that show....Carrie winning is a true sign most americans glued to their TVs are idiots. She has been butchering songs the last 3 weeks and I thought she slaugtered Martina Mcbrides song last night. Randy most be tone deaf...

Fat chic? you are joking right?

Yeah, you are joking. My sarcasm meter must be broken.

 

[Muadib]

Originally posted by: Doboji

Originally posted by: Muadib

Originally posted by: Ranger X
The contest has officially ended. Bo and Carrie will both be signed, no matter what.
Vonzelle will most likely be signed too but maybe with another record label.

Vonzelle > Chris Tucker with a bastard child from last season

It's not a matter of who will get signed, because most of those who make the top 12 get signed.

Carrie is the American Idol!! I hate Country, but her talent far out shines Bo's.

What crack are you smokin and where can I get some?

Who's smoking crack now, BIOTCH!!!

 

[Muadib]

Originally posted by: Duvie

Originally posted by: Pacfanweb

Originally posted by: Excelsior
Goddamnit don't bring politics into OT.


And I think Vonzell was a better singer than Carrie, and she should have won.

How in the hell can anyone think Vonzell was a better singer than Carrie? Carrie can sing throughout her whole vocal range.

Vonzell can only carry a tune when she's wailing. She constantly butchered songs that started out low.

As far as the show's winner....I'd say the right person won. Bo is a better performer, but not a better singer. American Idol is a singing competition.
Bo sang the old song Vehicle again tonight, and also last night. Both times, he was worse than the first time he sang it.
Plus, he sang wimpy, sappy songs for his other two last night. That wasn't his thing, and both were totally opposite from the songs he's been singing, for the most part.

I like both singers, and both will do well. Carrie may well sell more records than Kelly, who I'm sure must be the best seller of all the Idols.
She may have been better off losing, then signing a contract with a Nashville company, at least in the short run.
We'll have to let her Idol contract play out now, and wait until a real record company and producer get ahold of her to see what she can do.

I agree with some of it but as a country star she will not come anywhere close to outselling Kelly....If she goes pop she will be finished cause he really only sang country well....Both of them may have been too one dimensional anyways....Fantasia was and that is why she suxx...Reuben is and that is why he suxs....Clay had a bit more range and he could have done more but wants out of the life....

Carrie did performbeter last night cause I agree Bo blew the song choices...He needed to do more upbeat stuff....

Anybody who thought that carie rendition of Martina Mcbrde was good can join Randy in the tone deaf idiot club!!!

Both Reuben & Fantasia went platinum, how can you say they sucked?

 

[Muadib]

Originally posted by: Duvie

Originally posted by: Doboji

Originally posted by: Sphexi
And Carrie wins....dammit

yeah exactly....

BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO carrie sucks she's another example of this new world... where we worship the hot chic regardless of whether she has a brain or talent or anything else....

makes me kinda sick to my stomach frankly

-Max

Hot Chic?? Try fat chic...That girl is too thick for my liking and is as fun to watch on the stage as to listening to Michael Moore rant his conspiracy theories...

Anybody remember the comment Simon made like 8 weeks ago after she sang some song where he predicted " you will sell more records then any past idol winner"...Yeah Right!!!

Kelly rocks here...She has 3 songs in the top 40 and the album is in like the top 3 billboard charts...Simon said that as a satb against all the past idol winners who are usually more then glad to got out of their 1 year contract. Some like Clay use lawyers....

This will be a Clay/Reuben all over again... The second place finisher is going to rock the winner...She can go linger in obscurity with the once again waning country music genre...Bo is going to take off in a rival of rock.

Actually if you look at it last years suck-arse Fantasia has been outdone by Diana Degarmo who has a much more lucrative Disney contract and sold more albums I believe...

Reubens POS album tanked faster then his try at dieting!!! HAHAHAHA


Kelly is truly about the only one that has ever had talent out of that show....Carrie winning is a true sign most americans glued to their TVs are idiots. She has been butchering songs the last 3 weeks and I thought she slaugtered Martina Mcbrides song last night. Randy most be tone deaf...

You must not know that they all are under contracts with the show. Clay got out of his last year, so you can best believe that the contracts of this years group is rock solid.

As for Diana outselling Fantasia, Fantasia went platinum. Diana's album dropped faster than a mobster with concrete shoes on.

 

[SouthPaW1227]

i hate this show.

false talent exemplified. So what, a few people can sing. What about the amazing studio musicians and songwriters who get 0 credit and these losers would be NOTHING without.

/rant

gg carrie, Bo Bice was a horrible Edwin McCain ripoff

 

[Nitemare]

Originally posted by: Excelsior

Originally posted by: Pacfanweb

Originally posted by: Excelsior
Goddamnit don't bring politics into OT.


And I think Vonzell was a better singer than Carrie, and she should have won.

How in the hell can anyone think Vonzell was a better singer than Carrie? Carrie can sing throughout her whole vocal range.

Vonzell can only carry a tune when she's wailing. She constantly butchered songs that started out low.

As far as the show's winner....I'd say the right person won. Bo is a better performer, but not a better singer. American Idol is a singing competition.
Bo sang the old song Vehicle again tonight, and also last night. Both times, he was worse than the first time he sang it.
Plus, he sang wimpy, sappy songs for his other two last night. That wasn't his thing, and both were totally opposite from the songs he's been singing, for the most part.

I like both singers, and both will do well. Carrie may well sell more records than Kelly, who I'm sure must be the best seller of all the Idols.
She may have been better off losing, then signing a contract with a Nashville company, at least in the short run.
We'll have to let her Idol contract play out now, and wait until a real record company and producer get ahold of her to see what she can do.

Apparently me and many other people. Were you watching the same show? It doesn't matter anyway, because when they put out a record..their voice will be altered enough to make it sound quite good.

<insert Ashley Simpson reference>

 

[JonTom]

I think that Carrie beat Bo on the final performance night, unfortunately. The votes carried that through.

I am not a big fan of either, but I might maybe buy Bo's album, but I'll never buy Carrie's. Either way, I'm going to have to listen to it CONSTANTLY on the crappy/only radio station here in town

Am I the only one who laughed out loud at Constantine's Greek waiter?

 

[CTrain]

Lindsey was hot last night though.

 

[TheNinja]

Carrie is a great singer. And you have to remember who is voting. I'd say a majority of the votes come from teenages, especially girls. They might like Bo b/c he's a rugged southern rocker, but they love people like Carrie b/c it's who they aspire to be.

As mentioned, Carrie was a better singer but probably one of the worst performers....well besides Scotty the fatty.

And who's idea was it to bring back back loser #1 and his buddy super loser #2....was it Adam and Matt or something like that. The best part of the show when David Hasselhoff shows up to surprise that fat loser. Those two were so ambiguously gay.

 

[OCNewbie]

Originally posted by: TheNinja
The best part of the show when David Hasselhoff shows up to surprise that fat loser.

God I felt sorry for David Hasselhoff. I wonder if he really had to sit next to his #1 fan the remainder of the show, you know that had to be awkward and uncomfortable to him. Specially when his #1 fan seems to be a retard.

 

[DeMeo]

Originally posted by: OCNewbie

Originally posted by: TheNinja
The best part of the show when David Hasselhoff shows up to surprise that fat loser.

God I felt sorry for David Hasselhoff. I wonder if he really had to sit next to his #1 fan the remainder of the show, you know that had to be awkward and uncomfortable to him. Specially when his #1 fan seems to be a retard.

A just punishment for hasslehoff is you ask me.

 

[rh71]

Originally posted by: Excelsior

Originally posted by: rh71
bottom line... who's more of an idol ? The hot chick. That's the way it should be. They named the show American Idol. It has to have some pull, ALONG with talent (or even above it).

I don't know who wants to idolize Bo, or even Ruben. Clay I can see... Kelly and Fantasia I can see... and now Carrie I can easily see.

(Yes, I'm saying this show can very much be rigged when it comes to the final few - and who has the most appeal). Someone must've been sleeping when Ruben won though...

Even Fantasia?

...

Yes... because there are plenty of young black females who have dreams too... and she shows that it can be done. That's what being an idol is all about.