The good guys chat wasn't started until day 3.
Night 2 (effectively night 1 since we didn't get a chance to get together and appoint a leader the first night), Lucy tried recruiting Chiropteran and died for it.
Night 3, I, as new leader, recruited HCR, who turned out to be the bodyguard.
Day 3, I accused Ashenor in here of being too quiet, and he in PM called me out as the mason leader and said he was the gravedigger. Since there was no way for him to not know I was mason and HCR was bodyguard without really being the gravedigger, HCR and I started up a new non-Mason chat for all us, Ashenor, and the other two people Ashenor saw as gravedigger, Cuda (shaman) and ussfletcher (seer). I had made myself a bit of a target, and HCR bodyguarded me that night since he couldn't bodyguard the seer twice in a row. Looks like it worked out, because the wolves didn't get anyone.
From there, we found out ussfletcher had seen Zokudu as good. I recruited him to verify he wasn't the warlock.
My next and second blind recruitment was Storma, who came off as good to me in the chat, whom we found out was one of the hunters.
We went after psyjsay, partially because of me saying she's way more quiet this game than normal, but since Cuda had the totem of cowardice, we had him play it on her in case we were wrong (which it turns out we were).
By this time, we knew the roles of everyone but 5 people: ALIVE, El Fenix, gw, Xed, and Blueoak. We figured ElFenix and Blueoak were not on the same side because Blueoak voted for ElFenix multiple times in the game.
We lynched ElFenix that day, revealing him to be a warlock, which meant Blueoak was likely either the last hunter or the werehamster.
Since ALIVE claimed to be a hunter, and Cuda had the totem of protection, he played it on me, while I made myself a big target again for the wolves since they would think I couldn't be bodyguarded twice in a row, and recruited ALIVE overnight to see if he was telling the truth. Unfortunately, this plan didn't work as well as it should have, because Dixy made a mistake and didn't realize the totem should have protected me from all forms of death, and I was written off for trying to recruit the were-hamster.
Thus, since I died by trying to recruit ALIVE, he became the next target. Fortunately, he turned out to be the were-hamster, which meant Blueoak was probably the real hunter (who then claimed to be so the day ALIVE was lynched). That left Xed and gw (the latter of whom was seen as a were-creature by fletcher) as the remaining werewolves. Game over.
All said and done, I think the gravedigger was fine as long as private messaging isn't allowed. Then, if he's lucky enough to get recruited early in the game, the masons will only be able to bring one of the known good guys into the loop at a time. If he isn't recruited, all he knows is that there are 4 people he can trust.