Are You A Werewolf - Forum Game 9: THE VILLAGE WINS

[keird]

Oh noes! Chubbers just wanted to be successful with his wife and his career.

I has a sad.

 

[Charmonium]

Oh noes! Chubbers just wanted to be successful with his wife and his career.

I has a sad.

I feel bad too but he didn't really give us a choice. Any time you say things that makes it look like you are lying you make yourself a target. I don't think it was intentional. I think he just painted himself into a corner and couldn't get out.

 

[keird]

We're at loggerheads on them. I have a sense the masons or seer will eventually clear one or the other, making our decision clear.

I do want to hear from El Fenix though.

Really? We're down a Mason and you don't want to have a 50% chance of hitting a Werewolf? You vote random? While I agree that El Fenix's absence in the thread is suspicious, we have one of two guys who admit they were pumping the neighbor's cat! The other is a witness who can't have much effect on the end game, anyways.

PF or Chiropteran are the clear choices for me.

 

[glenn1]

Here's my plan; kill Ctbaars today, Chiropteran tomorrow, if he isn't a wolf we kill Possessed Freak the next day.

Sticking with the plan, we're on track so Chitoperan it is.

 

[Dr. Zaus]

Really? We're down a Mason and you don't want to have a 50% chance of hitting a Werewolf? You vote random? While I agree that El Fenix's absence in the thread is suspicious, we have one of two guys who admit they were pumping the neighbor's cat! The other is a witness who can't have much effect on the end game, anyways.

PF or Chiropteran are the clear choices for me.

I prefer the 100% we can get from the seer/monk; but I respect the point you're making.

I'll move off of El Fenix when he says enough to hang himself if he's a baddie.

 

[JujuFish]

Chiropteran

 

[Charmonium]

Really? We're down a Mason and you don't want to have a 50% chance of hitting a Werewolf? You vote random? While I agree that El Fenix's absence in the thread is suspicious, we have one of two guys who admit they were pumping the neighbor's cat! The other is a witness who can't have much effect on the end game, anyways.

PF or Chiropteran are the clear choices for me.

You make a good point, but my vote for El fenix is more on principle. We can't have players who don't participate. This can be for a variety of reasons, but unless the player comes here to explain those reasons and answer our questions, we should regard them with utmost suspicion. It's too easy to hide in plain site otherwise.

Granted that with PF and Chiro, we have a 50-50 chance of getting a wolf, but personally, I think the odds are higher for someone who is doing their best to hide. Plus I don't like the idea of taking out one of our own, even if they've already used their power.

Anyway, since I believe Chiro and not PF, my vote would be for PF if not for El Fenix.

 

[dustb0wlkid]

I see no reason to pick someone other than Chiropteran. So that's my vote for now.

 

[Chiropteran]

Something I'd like to point out. Between me and PF, one of us is a loner with no friends (the witness), the other is a wolf with several wolf friends who would be happy to lynch the witness.

So, this dogpile of lynch votes on me, IMO, is telling that PF is indeed the wolf, and some of those who are voting are probably his wolf friends.

 

[Charmonium]

Something I'd like to point out. Between me and PF, one of us is a loner with no friends (the witness), the other is a wolf with several wolf friends who would be happy to lynch the witness.

So, this dogpile of lynch votes on me, IMO, is telling that PF is indeed the wolf, and some of those who are voting are probably his wolf friends.

That's sound logic in my opinion. However the fact that there was an early push for El Fenix to be lynched which was then followed by piling on to Chiro tells me that Fenix is also probably a wolf and the votes for Chiro are designed to be a distraction from fenix rather than PF. I'm guessing we have 4 of them this game rather than the 3 we had last time.

So I will change from El Fenix to PF if we get enough people to go that way. Right now I want hear from the Fenix.

 

[dustb0wlkid]

Or it could be that it's 10:30 on a Saturday night. Or that he's seems more credible than you. Or that his voting has been less suspect then yours. And it's not like people haven't been coming to your defense. Amirite, Charmonium and Dixycrat?

 

[Charmonium]

Or it could be that it's 10:30 on a Saturday night. Or that he's seems more credible than you. Or that his voting has been less suspect then yours. And it's not like people haven't been coming to your defense. Amirite, Charmonium and Dixycrat?

I don't think anyone has voted for me yet in this game. If that happened, I don't think it was more than one vote.

Plus I have a special ability that could be very valuable to our team, as long as I don't get lynched.

 

[dustb0wlkid]

I was talking about Chiropteran, but it's interesting how defensive you are as well...

 

[arcenite]

Do bold your votes, people!

Chiropteran

 

[ElFenix]

elfenix is nothing but a normal villager. not even a prostitute

possessed freak smells funny, though.

 

[Bubbleawsome]

Here's my plan; kill Ctbaars today, Chiropteran tomorrow, if he isn't a wolf we kill Possessed Freak the next day.

I'm sticking to it. Chiropteran

 

[keird]

Here's my plan; kill Ctbaars today, Chiropteran tomorrow, if he isn't a wolf we kill Possessed Freak the next day.

This.

Chiropteran.

The Pear of Anguish! 'cause the Olive of Annoyance doesn't have the gravitas for this lynching.

 

[arcenite]

elfenix is nothing but a normal villager. not even a prostitute

possessed freak smells funny, though.

We'll all prostitutes in one way or another

 

[Possessed Freak]

I have no reason to change my vote, Chiropteran.

 

[A Casual Fitz]

Votes have been all over the place, I need to read all of the posts and I'll make my pick in a bit.

Edit, shrug. I don't know if I buy it but my vote won't change anything, so Chiropteran.

 

[Dr. Zaus]

Really? We're down a Mason and you don't want to have a 50% chance of hitting a Werewolf? You vote random? While I agree that El Fenix's absence in the thread is suspicious, we have one of two guys who admit they were pumping the neighbor's cat! The other is a witness who can't have much effect on the end game, anyways.

PF or Chiropteran are the clear choices for me.

For what it's worth, I don't trust this many people laying into one person: particularly when we know one is a wolf. Possessed Freak

 

[Charmonium]

For what it's worth, I don't trust this many people laying into one person: particularly when we know one is a wolf. Possessed Freak

Definitely. We have 17 people this game, well, we did have 17 people. Four are gone and I hope they're keeping each other company in the netherworld. The point is that with that many people to start, it's not inconceivable that we would have 4 wolves since that would be less than 25% of the players. And since the wolves got beaten so badly last game, perhaps god has taken pity on them.

If so, we really need to lynch a wolf soon or we're all going to be on the menu. I think El Fenix is a wolf but if a couple more people go for Possessed, I'd probably join in.

 

[Chiropteran]

possessed freak is a known wolf. Hopefully the numbers allow for him to be lynched. Worst case, I will get lynched and the truth will immediately be known- and those who cast accusations my way will look very wolfish. Make sure you pay attention to who is voting how.

 

[arcenite]

Chiro claims witness -- no one disputes that? Oh, I see PF does. Hence the love fest.

 

[keird]

possessed freak is a known wolf. Hopefully the numbers allow for him to be lynched. Worst case, I will get lynched and the truth will immediately be known- and those who cast accusations my way will look very wolfish. Make sure you pay attention to who is voting how.

We'll kill PF after, then. It's not personal we're just bracketing a wolf.