Are you a Werewolf? (game #4: Werewolfs Win)

[schneiderguy]

I don't think Zeze nor InfinityOctopus have really done anything to deserve being lunched (well besides Zeze's drunken rants ). IMO psyjay is the wolf. There's no reason for the actual bodyguard to come out like that so early in the game.

 

[Cuda1447]

I agree with schneider, I vote to lynch psyjay

 

[Ashenor]

I am going no vote today. I don't have enough to go on without endangering a innocent.

 

[JujuFish]

4 votes for psyjsay, 3 for InfinityOctopus, if I'm reading the votes correctly.
Hmm.

 

[LightRider]

I think the psy bandwagon is a bit premature. No other person has outright contradicted her claim to that role. I think the wolf-double-bluff theory is kind of silly.

 

[schneiderguy]

I think the psy bandwagon is a bit premature. No other person has outright contradicted her claim to that role. I think the wolf-double-bluff theory is kind of silly.

Why would someone contradict her claim? If I was the bodyguard I wouldn't be advertising that fact :whiste:

Since we have to lynch someone (unless the vote is tied) I think it's less premature to lynch psyjsay than InfinityOctopus.

 

[LightRider]

Why would someone contradict her claim? If I was the bodyguard I wouldn't be advertising that fact :whiste:

Since we have to lynch someone (unless the vote is tied) I think it's less premature to lynch psyjsay than InfinityOctopus.

Well, I lean towards IO because I favor eating wolf meat and not cabbages. I don't think psyj has stated an opinion on appropriate foodstuffs this entire game.

 

[psyjsay]

If you can't kill me tonight talk the village into killing me because a body gaurd mucks up the works.

But I will say this perhaps my expierience playing this live has ill prepared me for this. You can not see certainty or honesty.

How about logic

why did no one die if majority can win it? Even with the loss of alive there is two wolf kin three wolves. Only three have the kill votes which makes it odd that all three decieded to hang on to three different votes in order to make a draw.

 

[drum]

I voting HardcoreRobot. I am not feeling hardcores theory and I agree with psy. dont know why she revealed or really think it was a great idea but i don't think it is a lie

 

[psyjsay]

Another interesting point

To lynch me now is rediculous for the village they have little to gain.
Werewolves have more to gain from my death, as I am the friking body gaurd.so why not use the lynch on someone else. If I survive the night because the wolves did not eat me, you can lynch me next day following the suspicions I died for.

 

[Zeze]

Another interesting point

To lynch me now is rediculous for the village they have little to gain.
Werewolves have more to gain from my death, as I am the friking body gaurd.so why not use the lynch on someone else. If I survive the night because the wolves did not eat me, you can lynch me next day following the suspicions I died for.

The whole pont of lynching you as proposed by hardcorerobot is tha tyou may be double bluffing. It can't be half way. It's one or the other all the way:

1. wolves don't attack on purpose, planted you as a fake body guard (Which is why they want to kill u)

2. you are a true bodyguard and made a bad mistake of revealing yurself. In such case, wolves know for 100%, therefore will kill you.

You are dead 100% by tomorrow, either by us or wolves,.

Bad move overall.

 

[psyjsay]

I revealed because in live game the situation indicates high probability I was going to be eaten next night.

I can hindsight and learn from this experience later.

 

[LightRider]

Another interesting point

To lynch me now is rediculous for the village they have little to gain.
Werewolves have more to gain from my death, as I am the friking body gaurd.so why not use the lynch on someone else. If I survive the night because the wolves did not eat me, you can lynch me next day following the suspicions I died for.

I'm concerned that you are avoiding the very important matter of dietary opinions.

 

[psyjsay]

I feel 100% they already know, so I think by telling the village they at least can start looking around my death to try to find the wolves.

Because if I would feel foolish being 100% sure that they already know and did not warn my village. That would be a gross personal failure.

 

[Zeze]

I revealed because in live game the situation indicates high probability I was going to be eaten next night.

I can hindsight and learn from this experience later.

I don't follow how your move would be wise in a live game. What's the difference?

Well anyway, just a game. We all make mistakes.

NOW WHERE IS MA DRINK???????? IT'S 9PEE EM AND TIME TO PARTY!!

 

[psyjsay]

I'm concerned that you are avoiding the very important matter of dietary opinions.

I don't believe my village is cannibalistic. Should they chose to lunch me, they would find it in their hearts to bury my human remains. Not eat them.

 

[drum]

I feel 100% they already know, so I think by telling the village they at least can start looking around my death to try to find the wolves.

Because if I would feel foolish being 100% sure that they already know and did not warn my village. That would be a gross personal failure.

you say that as if you role is not revealed after your death

 

[psyjsay]

So if im 100% dead by the wolves, why should the village waste a lunch on someone that is dead anyways?

 

[drum]

So if im 100% dead by the wolves, why should the village waste a lunch on someone that is dead anyways?

i'm with you on that point.

 

[psyjsay]

you say that as if you role is not revealed after your death

That is not how I say it at all.
If you really think about it.

I talk as though my role would be revealed after death.
I as body gaurd protected myself.
I know I stepped on some toes trying to provoke some wolf.
No death occurs

So I can only assume I ticked off the right wolf. I can also assume that if I am alive because I was a target I can strongly assume that they could guess at my role. Because who am I? This is my first game and you have a first day lunch tradition already. Why would some other body gaurd protect a no one?

Second it is possible that because of my reveal maybe I can help find a wolf. My opening assumption is I ticked off a wolf.

 

[drum]

that is a pretty good strategy. you get BG role, decide to bait a handful of people hoping to get a wolf to try to kill at night. you protect yourself, and noone dies so you can be pretty sure you were targeted.
you are thinking outing this info is worth being able to id and get a wolf killed, especially since a wolf was already killed the first day.

 

[psyjsay]

Well my suspicion is still hardcore robot.
Why is he making the village waste a lunch on the obviously dead by wolves me?

 

[psyjsay]

I still think I would need to come out when I feel certain I'm dead anyways because the situation has a very high probability that they would kill me next anyways.

Again hindsight. there are more than one way to die with grace. But I know for sure my game was short.

So zee zee pass me a drink. I at least die feeling like I did what I could for the village I love.

 

[psyjsay]

If I can think of anything more, I'll sure do it. I'm not giving up on my village. I'm just out of something useful to say without repeating myself.

 

[LightRider]

If I can think of anything more, I'll sure do it. I'm not giving up on my village. I'm just out of something useful to say without repeating myself.

If you really are who you say you are, then who do you think is worthy of protection tonight? Assuming you are voted to death, then telling us your power target would be meaningless. If you escape the vote and are killed by the wolves one kill, then the target is spared. Give us a clue who you think should be considered good.