Are you a Werewolf? (game #4: Werewolfs Win)

[Zeze]

So zee zee pass me a drink. I at least die feeling like I did what I could for the village I love.

So.. in this game you're not married to Dixy and a single yes?

TADTS THE SPIRIT YA foxy Lady! Let'S DRUNK up and hELP me steal dat 18 yo bottle of Whisky that damn no-good salad-eatin ASHENOR is hiding frm me.

Tonighe we celvete two things:

1. Your glorius short life here in dis village.

3. Dat SSSnail and Elfix talked about the wrewolves and at post #79 & #88, whcih send us to the signififcnt jive at town well bettuh not be poiznined.

SHEERS!@

 

[Zeze]

AAHH AHHAAH AHAHA ASHENORRRRRR U WENCH Why arent u at your saloon? I got me a bbeuuutiful date with Psyjsuy!!! She smells like my late wife Eleanor. MMmm...

We' don gunna help our selvse at your BARahjahah!

 

[psyjsay]

If you really are who you say you are, then who do you think is worthy of protection tonight? Assuming you are voted to death, then telling us your power target would be meaningless. If you escape the vote and are killed by the wolves one kill, then the target is spared. Give us a clue who you think should be considered good.

That's like asking me who I think the seer is. I'm not going to do that.

 

[Chiropteran]

I think psy is being honest, and I feel we are just wasting a lynch in killing her. But I don't have a good alternative. I remain nonvoting, although I have a few minor suspicions about some villagers.

 

[SSSnail]

I still think these are the wolves and will need to be lynched eventually:

Lazarus52980
Krazy4real
Zeze
InfinityOctopus

Maybe:
Chiropteran
psyjsay

 

[psyjsay]

So.. in this game you're not married to Dixy and a single yes?

TADTS THE SPIRIT YA foxy Lady! Let'S DRUNK up and hELP me steal dat 18 yo bottle of Whisky that damn no-good salad-eatin ASHENOR is hiding frm me.

Tonighe we celvete two things:

1. Your glorius short life here in dis village.

3. Dat SSSnail and Elfix talked about the wrewolves and at post #79 & #88, whcih send us to the signififcnt jive at town well bettuh not be poiznined.

SHEERS!@

True gamers know, be true to the game. Play the game, respect other gamers. If you play a false game no one will game with you. I love to play.

I also have my honor, just because I'm going to die, I am not going to steal. Buy if my money is good, I'll buy a cup for zee zee.

 

[Zeze]

I still think these are the wolves and will need to be lynched eventually:

Lazarus52980
Krazy4real
Zeze
InfinityOctopus

Maybe:
Chiropteran
psyjsay

U TOOK M<Y DEER ELEANOR FROM ME And NOW U SAY IM WOLF? BLood is seething from Me EYES.

Yu no-good dirty 2-cent WHOR. I MAY BE A WOLF , But the LAST THIng I AM is a DrUNK.

 

[Chiropteran]

I still think these are the wolves and will need to be lynched eventually:

Lazarus52980
Krazy4real
Zeze
InfinityOctopus

Maybe:
Chiropteran
psyjsay

Say what you will about me, but krazy4real voted to lynch ALIVE, who would have been known as a werewolf to the other wolves. Seems unlikely a wolf would lynch another wolf the first turn of the game, when there really isn't any suspicion in abstaining.

 

[LightRider]

That's like asking me who I think the seer is. I'm not going to do that.

Well it's just your opinion. You obviously have no real clue who the seer is, unless you have cheated. You might have also been simultaneously attacked, guarded and mason'd on night one, which means that you know who the masons are. But that is even too far fetched for this game, beyond everything else that's happened. So you would have nothing more to work on then the information we all commonly share. You said you wanted to help the village out. As a villager, I want some information in exchange for your suicidal behavior and loss of important role.

Unless you're really pulling the wolf-double-bluff, in which case we shall dine on your wolfy flesh!

 

[psyjsay]

Well it's just your opinion. You obviously have no real clue who the seer is, unless you have cheated. You might have also been simultaneously attacked, guarded and mason'd on night one, which means that you know who the masons are. But that is even too far fetched for this game, beyond everything else that's happened. So you would have nothing more to work on then the information we all commonly share. You said you wanted to help the village out. As a villager, I want some information in exchange for your suicidal behavior and loss of important role.

Unless you're really pulling the wolf-double-bluff, in which case we shall dine on your wolfy flesh!

Villagers have more to gain from who I think the wolves are.
Only wolves would benifit from who I think should be safe.

 

[schneiderguy]

Say what you will about me, but krazy4real voted to lynch ALIVE, who would have been known as a werewolf to the other wolves. Seems unlikely a wolf would lynch another wolf the first turn of the game, when there really isn't any suspicion in abstaining.

Last game a couple of the wolves voted to lynch wolves. I'm not placing too much weight on who voted to lynch who this game.

ALIVE was the "unknowing" werewolf, so he wasn't that valuable to the wolves anyway. Sounds like a good time to cast a couple of votes towards him and then have those players be free from suspicion the rest of the game.

 

[LightRider]

Villagers have more to gain from who I think the wolves are.
Only wolves would benifit from who I think should be safe.

If you claimed to be seer, that would be true, but you claim to be guard, which means you have to make a decision on who to guard.

 

[psyjsay]

I guess I should say then I am sorry to my village for creating a situation where they would waste a lynch on an already dead by wolves me.

 

[Chiropteran]

It seems to me the only a wolf would have to gain from lynching psy. Let her live, and they kill her at night. Lynch her, and they get to eat someone else as a free bonus.

Lynching her has all the risk and no gain.

If she is a wolf, then we are way ahead- we already got one wolf, and knowing the identity of a second wolf, even if we don't immediately lynch it, puts us way ahead.

But if she is innocent, and telling the truth, the wolves will almost certainly kill her tonight. They could let her live as some sort of bluff to make us think she is a wolf, but that hurts them- that means they have to let the bodyguard live to mess with their killings. I think they will just kill her.

We have nothing to gain by lynching psy tonight, if she does end up a wolf it's not going to hurt us to wait an extra night or two.

 

[psyjsay]

If you claimed to be seer, that would be true, but you claim to be guard, which means you have to make a decision on who to guard.

But that still means telling the wolves who I think is important. As a gaurd, even a dying one, I'll protect the who's that I think are important, by being silent.

 

[SSSnail]

Why do I think chiropteran and psyjsay are wolves? They're defending themselves heavily...

 

[Dr. Zaus]

^every time you bold you change who you are voting for^

 

[Chiropteran]

Last game a couple of the wolves voted to lynch wolves. I'm not placing too much weight on who voted to lynch who this game.

ALIVE was the "unknowing" werewolf, so he wasn't that valuable to the wolves anyway. Sounds like a good time to cast a couple of votes towards him and then have those players be free from suspicion the rest of the game.

I dunno, just seems with the number of players in the game and what, only 5 voting for ALIVE, it's not all that suspicious to be among the 10+ who abstain, why go out of your way to remove a potential win condition from your team, on turn 1 when there couldn't be much suspicion anyway?

 

[psyjsay]

Why do I think chiropteran and psyjsay are wolves? They're defending themselves heavily...

He is not defending himself at all.

And I'm just a sad about to die body gaurd upset that I caused my village to waste a lunch on me when when they could just let the wolves eat me. They (wolves)have every reason to eat me more than the villagers have to kill me. Because I can mess things up for the wolves.

 

[Chiropteran]

I still think these are the wolves and will need to be lynched eventually:

Lazarus52980
Krazy4real
Zeze
InfinityOctopus

Maybe:
Chiropteran
psyjsay

Also look at this. There are only 3 werewolfs and 2 werewolf kin left, and sssnail wants to lynch 6 people. Something here isn't right, someone is being a bit extra bloodthirsty and just wants to kill people for no reason.

It certainly helps the game move along, but I don't think anyone else should be taking SSSnail's lynch suggestions seriously.

 

[schneiderguy]

I dunno, just seems with the number of players in the game and what, only 5 voting for ALIVE, it's not all that suspicious to be among the 10+ who abstain, why go out of your way to remove a potential win condition from your team, on turn 1 when there couldn't be much suspicion anyway?

Everyone knew that ALIVE was going to be the Day 1 lynch, and it's good insurance for later, because they'll be able to point back and say "I'm not a wolf, I voted for ALIVE".

 

[HardcoreRobot]

It seems to me the only a wolf would have to gain from lynching psy. Let her live, and they kill her at night. Lynch her, and they get to eat someone else as a free bonus.

Lynching her has all the risk and no gain.

If she is a wolf, then we are way ahead- we already got one wolf, and knowing the identity of a second wolf, even if we don't immediately lynch it, puts us way ahead.

But if she is innocent, and telling the truth, the wolves will almost certainly kill her tonight. They could let her live as some sort of bluff to make us think she is a wolf, but that hurts them- that means they have to let the bodyguard live to mess with their killings. I think they will just kill her.

We have nothing to gain by lynching psy tonight, if she does end up a wolf it's not going to hurt us to wait an extra night or two.

i did not realize or remember the bodyguard could not protect the same 2 nights in a row. that doesnt really change much.

if we dont lynch her, the werewolfs don't need to kill her. they can go for someone else (very low chance they are guarded based on the numbers). because when she doesnt dies, she gets lynched tomorrow by the town anyway.

even if your logic was true, there is still no point in revealing your role. it cannot positively affect the townspeople. as soon as the wolves were blocked on you, they know you will be able to be killed the next night (again assuming bodyguard cant protect 2x in a row). when you die your role is revealed. there is nothing the town can do with that knowledge. you are a walking dead man.

i guess my ultimate point is, if the wolves play it right they will turn your reveal into a free lynch for them anyway so it doesnt matter if the lynch is today or tomorrow.

 

[psyjsay]

I was dead by wolves already, at least the villagers can become suspicious of the ones around my death when my role is confirmed in death.

 

[psyjsay]

But they are wasting a lynch on me

I am sorry for that

Ps hardcore I don't see you changing your vote

 

[Chiropteran]

even if your logic was true, there is still no point in revealing your role. it cannot positively affect the townspeople. as soon as the wolves were blocked on you, they know you will be able to be killed the next night (again assuming bodyguard cant protect 2x in a row). when you die your role is revealed. there is nothing the town can do with that knowledge. you are a walking dead man.

If you take her at her word, then they already tried to kill her and were blocked. It's only logical they would go for her again and get the kill.

The alternative being a "hung jury" among wolves deciding who to kill seems extremely unlikely, among other things there were 3 wolves so 1 would have to have been afk and the other 2 were each voting for different targets... it seems unlikely to me that they would waste their kill for any reason.