Originally posted by: Anubis
Originally posted by: rivan
Originally posted by: Anubis
Rivan, it has less to do with them doing it all on beta and more to do with it being STUPIDILY EASY, because well it is. Naxx is 2+ years old, i could go in there blindfolded and tell people how to do every boss as i did that content back before TBC came out, the other 2 raids are also easy, hell they were PUGGED on beta without my issue in those PVP Blues they gave you
So you're saying that I could, at 80 (or lower?), throw together a PUG in blues and knock the place over?
If that's the case, then there's probably something else up Blizzard's sleeve. It'd be totally out of character for them.
That really depends on your gear lvl, SK/nihl were in Full T6/sunwell and replaced basicially nothing, im in Full T6/Sunwell and im lvl 76 and i have replaced nothing as well. simply because that gear was somewhat insane, so we/they in effect have a huge gear advantage, those that do not will have a harder time. but yes it should still be puggable at 80 (the non heroic anyway) and the heroic with people that 1) arnt bad and 2) have decent gear
So if I'm a full time raider picking up full time raiders I can PUG it. Great. That's very different from a real PUG, and 90% of the people you pick up for a PUG won't have full T4 gear, much less T6, at least on my server.
From my point of view, the other extreme's been a problem thus far, where the only way to see most of this stuff is if you're willing to work your ass off to a) get yourself into a "raiding guild" which (by necessity) has to be a bunch of pricks about scheduling, then b) commit to the part-time job that is 25-man raiding. The very vocal raiding minority has had it their way for several years.
This is not true, we are not all pricks and some raiding guilds are VERY casual 2-3 nights a week for 2-4 hours
Not everyone's a prick, you're right. In my experience, though, guilds who are/were farming T6 gear (or other raids, even raiding in other games) were led by highly motivated people who don't really care a lick about the guy who can only make a raid once a month. With a single huge exception in
my experiences those guilds have a jackass at the controls. The rest have been chock full of people who will throw you under the bus to get an extra .02% DPS increase.
I'm not suggesting raiders should have nothing, and maybe you're (and the above-labeled douches) right about the new "end-game" content being weaksauce. If it is, I'm sure enough of an outcry will be made that the dungeon difficulty will be put through the roof such that the people who don't play 30 hours a week won't ever see it.
You know what I'd love to see? Percentages of accounts that have historically done these high end raids. Myself, I just did AQ40 for the first time. Haven't done AQ20 yet, but it's surely PUGable now (and I might be able to get a group now that there are achievements). Hopefully around 80 my little guild can hit the Sunwell. I want to know what % of the player base is really this "hard core". I know they make a whole lot of noise, but that's sort of expected - they're much more organized, motivated and outspoken about what they want from the game.
WTF im a douche now? I dont think instances need to be impossibily hard i just dont feel they need to be a joke either, Personally im more of a fan of making shit really overtuned and then nerfing it down like they did in TBC with Gruul/mag/heroics
BT pre 3.0 really was not that hard and neither was SSC and TK, Sunwell was the only really stupid hard instance that was pretty much given to raiders because we were bored at farming BT for the past 9 months
as for Percentages, 5% of all playes at lvl 60 before TBC saw the inside of Naxx 2% actually killed KT
Pre 3.0 the numbers were about the same for Sunwell, Higher for BT like 20% ish IIRC
Wow progress has them listed on their main page
No, you're not a douche - but you might be right about the state of the end-game content (like the douches originally linked who've already finished it and are bitching about being "done").
As for BT and higher being hard, I wouldn't know. I wasn't geared enough to make it through ZA apparently, so never even tried BT (I left the game for a year or two, only recently back and only recently 70.) What I do know is that I never once, even post-nerfs, saw anyone recruiting for a BT PUG. Or a Hyjal PUG. Or a SSC PUG. The PUGs I saw being recruited for stopped at Kara and once in a great while ZA. I'm not in a gear-driven guild (been there, done that) and just have a different gaming reality than you, I guess.
I'm talking about accounts - real people, not characters - there's (probably) a huge difference. I'd imagine you saw the inside of BT with more than one or two characters.
How does that site track who's been inside a given dungeon, beyond perhaps gear sourcing?