Geeez........how hard is it to read people?
Go to ATI's main page, mouse over the upper nav. bar on products, clcik on the trade-up link.....takes you to
THIS PAGE.
Look at the second product in the first section, the one marked RADEON Product Line......lo and behold, it's a RADEON 9800 PRO 128MB AGP card at ..... GASP...... $199.
Click on the Trade-Up Now! link at the right end of the box (the one marked US) and it puts a 9800 PRO 128MB AGP video card in your cart at $199. Put the code in for the 10% off and it comes to $179 and change.
NOWHERE does it say they charge you the $50 credit for a $50 return later (which would be rather stupid.....to take $50 just to give it back later..............that'd be no credit at all, just a loan to ATI.)
NOWHERE on the form that you can download from that same box does it say INVALID with the PROMO that's going on, we're going to charge you the $50 credit up front, etc. etc.
It only asks that you send in ANY video card within 15 days of ordering with the form, the UPC code from the box (it's a retail card you're getting, not a brown/OEM packaged thing), and a copy of the receipt (which shows you bought a trade-up product.)