ATOT Mafia #2 [Live]

[Kirby64]

Ok, I say we lynch Cuda since he was arguing against Dixy's reasoning which put doubt in the doc's mind.

Sounds reasonable to me... he seemed a bit overly eager to blame Dixy; none of us really knew anything at that point. Although Dixy WAS lying, he (probably (almost certainly)) was a mason.

Lynch vote goes to: Cuda1447 (for now...)

 

[Kirby64]

I vote to lynch DLeRium. I do this only becuase unless I miss read, he was AFK the whole first day, so he is either guilty (mafia, serial killer etc.) or he is just not participating. Either way, he is doing us no good.

If I missed that he at least posted somewhere, then please let me know and I will look at changing my vote.

Wait, why was he AFK the whole day? He didn't vote I guess? I ought to keep track of these things...

 

[InverseOfNeo]

Sounds reasonable to me... he seemed a bit overly eager to blame Dixy; none of us really knew anything at that point. Although Dixy WAS lying, he (probably (almost certainly)) was a mason.

Lynch vote goes to: Cuda1447 (for now...)

Since the masons can't do anything anymore, I will come out and say I was a mason and Dixy was as well.

Dixy was saying he was the leader to try to keep Alive from being killed.

 

[schneiderguy]

Baked, Gibson486, and HardcoreRobot also didn't put in a vote on Day 1, haven't checked if they posted or not.

edit: Baked has been MIA completely, Gibson and HardcoreRobot both posted but didn't vote.

 

[Kirby64]

Since the masons can't do anything anymore, I will come out and say I was a mason and Dixy was as well.

Dixy was saying he was the leader to try to keep Alive from being killed.

Interesting information; makes sense, seems trustworthy enough I suppose... although the other (presumed) masons can't back that up anymore :/ In fact, all the masons might be dead. Which is unfortunate, cause you could totally be mafia >< I want to believe Neo!

My only question: Why would Dixy hide behind ussfletcher? If he wasn't a Mason, that seems silly to hide behind someone who MIGHT be evil.

 

[InverseOfNeo]

I was the third mason. There's no reason to hide it anymore. We believed USSFletcher was innocent or at least unlikely to be killed.

 

[InverseOfNeo]

Though now that I have labeled myself as innocent, I would not be surprised if I was killed 'tonight'.

 

[Kirby64]

I was the third mason. There's no reason to hide it anymore. We believed USSFletcher was innocent or at least unlikely to be killed.

Why risk on an uncertainty? What downside would Dixy have gotten from hiding behind you, instead of fletcher?

 

[InverseOfNeo]

Good question, I didnt think of telling him to hide behind me. Either way, Alive, the mason leader, is dead and I can't recruit.

 

[schneiderguy]

Good question, I didnt think of telling him to hide behind me.

:hmm:

 

[TreyRandom]

With 21 left it takes 11 to lynch.

With 10 Mafia out there, good luck with that.

 

[mafia]

I say we lynch Gibson486. Something tells me that he is quiet. Perhaps, too quiet :hmm:

 

[drum]

Since the masons can't do anything anymore, I will come out and say I was a mason and Dixy was as well.

Dixy was saying he was the leader to try to keep Alive from being killed.

Edited: misunderstood secondary masons were townies with primary roles already instead of just powerless vanilla townies.

 

[drum]

And i'm holding off on a Cuda vote. I'm not voting for the guy who was able to sniff through Dixy's BS

 

[Cuda1447]

I was the third mason. There's no reason to hide it anymore. We believed USSFletcher was innocent or at least unlikely to be killed.

InverseofNeo is lying. He is not a Mason, all the Masons are dead. If he's not a Mason then he must be mafia, otherwise he wouldn't try to claim an innocent role. I'm open for discussion, but my early vote goes to lynching InverseofNeo

 

[drum]

InverseofNeo is lying. He is not a Mason, all the Masons are dead. If he's not a Mason then he must be mafia, otherwise he wouldn't try to claim an innocent role. I'm open for discussion, but my early vote goes to lynching InverseofNeo

Am I misinterpreting Zokudo's night post? The only mason that is dead is ALIVE, who was the mason leader. There should still be 2 regular no power masons out there. InverseofNeo is full of crap, but what you posted is wrong too. EDIT: YES I was misinterpreting Zokudu's post... disregard this post

 

[mnewsham]

You guys are so split you could probably end in a no lynch again and end up getting F'd by the mafia a second night in a row. Good luck but this game is pretty much already decided.

 

[Cuda1447]

Am I misinterpreting Zokudo's night post? The only mason that is dead is ALIVE, who was the mason leader. There should still be 2 regular no power masons out there. InverseofNeo is full of crap, but what you posted is wrong too.

I apologize, I misread an earlier post. I was confused by InverseofNeo's doubletalk. Either way, it is clear he is lying about something.

 

[HardcoreRobot]

btw, i voted no lynch in post http://forums.anandtech.com/showpost.php?p=33470175&postcount=176

ill post my personal diagnosis of the nights events later

 

[Cuda1447]

I was the third mason. There's no reason to hide it anymore. We believed USSFletcher was innocent or at least unlikely to be killed.

This doesn't make any sense. If Dixy was a Mason and you were a Mason, there is no way Dixy would have hid behind someone who had lynch votes AND you didn't know if he was a Mason or not. We know that Alive was the Mason leader.


So Either:

1. Alive, Dixy were Masons and Dixy hid behind the only other innocent he knew, USSFletcher, also a Mason. Which means you cannot be a Mason because all the Masons are dead.

2. Dixy wasn't a Mason, thus he was guessing who to hid behind - which means you are lying about Dixy being a Mason and you are not a Mason either.



Either way, you've got some 'splainin to do, because it looks like you've been caught RED HANDED as a liar.

 

[jmolayal]

InverseofNeo gets my vote. This Mafia SoB is lying. None of his BS makes any sense...

 

[waggy]

comon people come up with good reasons to lynch someone. i gotta admit i have no clue on who to lynch now.

 

[vshah]

damn, can't decide between cuda or inverse...have to spend some time reading through events leading up to last night.

 

[ViviTheMage]

Why would anyone out that they were mason? That just puts a target on their back from the mafia...

 

[waggy]

damn, can't decide between cuda or inverse...have to spend some time reading through events leading up to last night.

cuda argued points. and looks as if he caught invers in a lie. Unless something comes up i think i will flip a coin between them to. but i suspect people will yak like the dead did.