EliteRetard
Diamond Member
- Mar 6, 2006
- 6,490
- 1,021
- 136
My comment about milk acidity was mostly in relation to causing of heart burn. And the studies showed that less than 3 cups a day of milk to not be detrimental to bone health, and that dairy products like cheese and yogurt actually help bone health and and reduced risked of death in the groups that were studied.
Strictly speaking your information is outdated.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26445771
The article you link actually supports my position. They link many studies, however their interpretation of the results is often different than that of the actual study...trying to put a more positive spin on the results.
For example: Study 4 [141] where they state "...the exception was ankle fractures, which significantly decreased with increasing milk intake"
The actual study says "...there was some suggestion of reduced risk of ankle fractures with increased dietary calcium intake" (which included non dairy calcium supplements)
There are many studies suggesting little to no positive effect of milk/dairy intake, and several studies showing adverse effects including higher mortality rates linked to higher milk consumption.
In fact they directly state the following:
Up to two-thirds of the population’s calcium intake in Western countries is supplied by dairy products [6, 7]
Hip fracture rates are in fact highest in countries with high calcium intake and lowest where calcium intake is lower (the opposite to what might be expected) [69]
Anyway, I'm not going to debate this any further here...somebody can start a new thread if they wish. I think my point stands, milk/dairy is not a "healthy" food as claimed (despite it's high calcium content) and can in fact be detrimental to health. Especially in larger quantities or combined with other unhealthy foods...like in the average American diet today, high in processed foods meats dairy etc and low in real fruits and vegetables.
I'd be willing to concede that some dairy is O.K. as long as the daily average intake of ALL dairy sources combined is low, and it's followed up with a healthy diet containing a high percentage of a good variety of fruits and vegetables.
Last edited: