This is a hard one.
I should have suggestions by Im drawing a blank.
I'd say something with a lot of thunder, rain, stormy, creaky sounds, an old dark and creepy isolated mansion, and no silly monsters.
Something where the norm is a little twisted.
Like with my favorite classic film THE BAD SEED, where a seemingly pleasant all American little girl is actually a mass murderer.
Something you'd never expect.
But whatever the Halloween film, there must be a lot of crashing thunder, lightening and creaks.