Well I successfully scored the "Buy 2 Platinum Hits, get a 3rd FREE" deal at both CC and Best Buy yesterday (last day the deal was on).
I scored:
Max Payne
Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind (green package)
Silent Hill 2
Blood Wake
Tony Hawk Pro Skater 3
either SSX Tricky or Starfighter SE (not sure which one to keep, any suggestions?)
ES3 took a LOT of doing, since it is listed as Platinum on Xbox.com (I took a printout from the website with me), but hasn't been released in the Platinum packaging yet. CC didn't have it, but a BB up the street did. They didn't mind PMing the CC deal, but gave me all kinds of crap about ES3 not being a Platinum title, since it wasn't in the Platinum packaging. Never mind that everywhere else on Earth any existing green box stock of Platinum titles immediately drops in price when the Platinum status is announced. :|
And as it went on, the numbskulls at Customer Service were too stupid to understand what I was saying about ES3 being announced as a Platinum title and how there was no way in H-E-Double Hockey Stick I was paying an extra $10 damn dollars for it.
I went up to another BB about 15 minutes...smooth as silk, other than I had stormed off from the first BB in such a mood that I forgot to take the damn CC sale paper with me. CSR at the 2nd BB had a heckuva time getting anybody at CC to answer the phone.
She did me a solid tho. She told me her family has an Xbox (and other consoles) and while she was on hold we talked games and other assorted stuff. When she got all the info...she presented it in a VERY favorable light to the 2nd manager (altho the 1st manager I spoke to had already approved it, he was unavailable by the time she got done on the phone with CC) and he said "No problem at all...do the match."
Got the distinct impression she wanted to make the deal for herself later. That ALWAYS helps!