Originally posted by: loki8481
Originally posted by: Fern
Richardson criticized the role the super delegates will play in the decision, saying that the nomination should be decided by voters.
^That looks to be the important part. Sounds like he'll casting his SD ballot for Obama.
Fern
how do you define voters, though? which is to say, are the people of FL and MI in fact, voters?
We'll seems significant to me.
Firstly, all this "who has the best chance to win the gen election" stuff the Clinton camp is pushing seems out of consideration. In fact, I think it would be a good idea if all the SD's would take that as a pledge. As I said for a while, I think Hillary's gonna try to make Obama look bad so he falls behind in head-to-head polls with McCain and then use that as leverage to get herself chosen by the SD's. Hillary is thought to have a higher "floor" than Obama, so she should theoretically benefit from dirty campaigning.
For the SD's to chose popular votes over delegates strikes me as stupid. First, it's an admission that the very system they devised sucks. You've just overruled every state and how they chose to allocate their delegates (between districts etc). They made those choices for what they believed was good reason. Overrule it and you're gonna have some very unhappy campers.
Secondly, there's be a lot of comment about how unfair that is to the candidate who did better in caucuses (Obama of course) E.g., Colorado has a decent number of delegates and is a fairly populous state, but Obama is only credited with 80K votes and Hillary at 40k. IIRC a pledged delegate is worth about 10K votes. But Colorado has far more than 12 delegates, it has 55.
The caucus states are also gonna be pissed because counting popular votes vastly diminishes their importance and vioce/influence in the selection of the nominee. They'd end up being punished for following the rules, and people are gonna scream if they do that. Based my Colorado example above, the state would effectively be reduced from 55 delegates down to about 12 (about an 80% difference).
If the Dems wanna a repeat of the '68 convention, fine. But I think cooler heads will prevail and the nomination w/b chosen based on pledged (elected) delegates.
Fern