can u solve this

[wildcat86]

the smoking section was on fire, hence why it was smoking, so, the fire would have killed him instead of the gun

 

[vrbaba]

hint added

 

[WW]

he was going blind in town A, and moved to town B and had an eye operation...

on the train, he was asleep, but woke up as it was entering a long tunnel, then thinking his eyes went bad again, he killed himself....if he had been in the smoking car, he would have seen the lit cigarettes!

 

[jalaram]

The train was passing by Town A, but only the non-smoking section could see it? He saw it, got depressed, and killed himself? If he sat on the other side (smoking), he wouldn't have seen Town A.

 

[vrbaba]

Originally posted by: WW
he was going blind in town A, and moved to town B and had an eye operation...

on the train, he was asleep, but woke up as it was entering a long tunnel, then thinking his eyes went bad again, he killed himself....if he had been in the smoking car, he would have seen the lit cigarettes!

WINNAAA

good job. did you know it already, or figured out after the hint?

 

[Ramma2]

The doctor had told him that he was allergic to dinosaurs, so that even added more motivation for him to pull the trigger.

 

[amoeba]

Originally posted by: WW
he was going blind in town A, and moved to town B and had an eye operation...

on the train, he was asleep, but woke up as it was entering a long tunnel, then thinking his eyes went bad again, he killed himself....if he had been in the smoking car, he would have seen the lit cigarettes!

this has got to be it.

 

[dighn]

Originally posted by: vrbaba

Originally posted by: WW
he was going blind in town A, and moved to town B and had an eye operation...

on the train, he was asleep, but woke up as it was entering a long tunnel, then thinking his eyes went bad again, he killed himself....if he had been in the smoking car, he would have seen the lit cigarettes!

WINNAAA

good job. did you know it already, or figured out after the hint?

wow... without those "hints", any number of solutions could have fit the given data

 

[Vegitto]

He was depressed and thought of killing himself. His (smoking) doctor was not in his compartiment, thus not able to stop him?

 

[meltdown75]

i'm never playing this game again. ever

 

[Tommunist]

Originally posted by: vrbaba

Originally posted by: WW
he was going blind in town A, and moved to town B and had an eye operation...

on the train, he was asleep, but woke up as it was entering a long tunnel, then thinking his eyes went bad again, he killed himself....if he had been in the smoking car, he would have seen the lit cigarettes!

WINNAAA

good job. did you know it already, or figured out after the hint?

that's crap - what kind of train wouldn't have a single lightsource anywhere? and what does moving have to do with getting an eye operation?

 

[vshah]

worst riddle ever. billions...no..trillions of loose ends

 

[jdini76]

Hid doctor was a smoker, and was in the smoking section of the train. If he was in the smoking section, the doctor would have prevented him from killing himself?


Edit: I see that it was answered. I like mine better.

 

[wildcat86]

Originally posted by: vrbaba

Originally posted by: WW
he was going blind in town A, and moved to town B and had an eye operation...

on the train, he was asleep, but woke up as it was entering a long tunnel, then thinking his eyes went bad again, he killed himself....if he had been in the smoking car, he would have seen the lit cigarettes!

WINNAAA

good job. did you know it already, or figured out after the hint?

you didnt tell he was a moron!

 

[OdiN]

I got it!!

He shot you for asking such a retarded question, then couldn't live with himself so shot himself.

If he was in the smoking section, you woudln't have been there.

The solution isn't a solution. It assumes that, at the time of the tunnel, that there would be someone smoking in the other car. It is possible that would not be true.

It also assumes that if in a tunnel you cannot see anything...which is also untrue. What? Trains have lights on them? NO WAY!

 

[Vegitto]

Wow, what a dumbass solution to a dumbass question.

 

[leftyman]

godzilla should stomp on vrbaba

 

[Tommunist]

Originally posted by: vshah
worst riddle ever. billions...no..trillions of loose ends

if presented the right way it could be pretty good - but the jump to getting an eye operation and a train with no lights (exit signs or anything) make the leap to answer almost pure luck.

 

[Ramma2]

What tunnel could last longer than just a few minutes. I'm not going to go from full on sleep to groggy then shoot myself before I'm awake.

T-rex theory is much better.

 

[OdiN]

Originally posted by: Ramma2
What tunnel could last longer than just a few minutes. I'm not going to go from full on sleep to groggy then shoot myself before I'm awake.

T-rex theory is much better.

Also more probable I think

 

[amoeba]

this is a horrible riddle.

the parts about town A and town B are very misleading and the language makes it seem like it was a permanant move.

you could have left out that whole part and just said the doctor's part and it would have made a bit more sense.

 

[Ramma2]

Besides, town B doesn't allow conceal and carry.

 

[vrbaba]

its really supposed to be one of those 21 yes/no questions game... I was trying my best to answer the questions.
It does need some imagination. But you need to correlate being in the smoking vs. non-smoking section with something viable.

oh well, could have presented better...

 

[amoeba]

Originally posted by: vrbaba
its really supposed to be one of those 21 yes/no questions game... I was trying my best to answer the questions.
It does need some imagination. But you need to correlate being in the smoking vs. non-smoking section with something viable.

oh well, could have presented better...

I don't know, I thoguht the one concerning him trying to light a cig with his gun was pretty viable.

 

[OdiN]

Originally posted by: vrbaba
its really supposed to be one of those 21 yes/no questions game... I was trying my best to answer the questions.
It does need some imagination. But you need to correlate being in the smoking vs. non-smoking section with something viable.

oh well, could have presented better...

could have? rofl