Originally posted by: Scribe
Originally posted by: hscorpio
I find it strange that so many people downplay the role of religion in the current situation most muslims are in.
I might be wrong but weren't the muslims/middle easterners a more advanced society than europe at one point? The europeans advanced, had a renaissance and thrived, despite their religion which often stood in the way of progress. We know that terrible things were committed in the name of christianity like the inquisition, but europe changed, christianity changed and went through reformations and became more civilized.
But why hasn't Islam changed with the times? Thats why I think so many muslims are in such a bad situation. It is a combination of their religion and socio-economic factors. Part of the Islamic faith is that it is the one true and perfect religion. The koran is perfect and cannot be changed or interpreted differently. Questions can't be asked, its perfect, accept it or die. And so they stay chained down by an outdated religion. Today muslims see the west and all the freedom and success and they want that too. But then they know their religion forbids much of the western way of life and feel cheated and angry that they are living so poorly. Thats why I think they hate the west so much, it makes them have an identity crisis and doubt what is undoutable. Add in a severe education vacuum and you have a terrorist breeding ground.
Also Islam seems to be more predisposed to violance than modern christianity. Compare Mohamad to Jesus. Jesus was all about turn the other cheek, pray for your enemies, etc. Mohamad prefered to kill his enemies . Look at the Salman Rusdie thing from 89. Can you imagine the pope ordering a worldwide hit be placed on monty python for making fun of christianity. Practically the whole islamic world supported murdering Rushdie for writing a book.
Ahh thats enough opinionated ranting from this no0b
Yes, I completely agree with most of what you have to say. Having grown up Muslim (and then abandoned that religion and religion as a whole entirely) I know first hand what you're talking about, however there are a few caveats.
I wish it was the case that Muslims would 'get with the times' but unfortunately the clerics wield more power than the government in most countries. There's good reason for this though -- they can promise people food, housing, education -- all things that the governments cannot. So to go this route is the more popular one for most people in these countries and as a result, we have generation upon generation of those who hate the US and its allies.
The Muslim countries of the world, by in large, are very oil-rich countries. Now the imperial powers of Britain, France and the US (to a lesser extent) felt it would be in their best interest to 'back' leaders to be dictators and thus, undercut the price of oil for them. This is why the CIA overthrew a democratically elected official from Iran and reinstalled the Shah, a brutal dictator who was a crazy lunatic wielding religion as a weapon both offensive and defensively. People believed him too -- where else were they going to get proof? The internet wasn't around to prove the Shah wrong, and there was no independant media, so there are generations of people that believe what the Shah had to say, and also when the Shah said "im gonna git u sucka" to Salman Rushdie, then all of Iran was with him on that.
Saudi Arabia's another country like that. Did you know in the Quran that a monarchy is EXPRESSLY forbidden? Yet the Saudi Royal Family has been running a 'religious' police that beats people in public (and worse) for not following the religion, while the Saudis run to Turkey to get hookers and booze, and also have made the Guiness Book of World Records for the most money lost EVER in gambling. And the US supports them wholeheartedly, without question, so the Saudi people hate us for it. They are being repressed by an illigitmate regime backed by the US, and that's what Osama capitalized on -- fighting the enemies of the Saudis including the Saudis themselves.
Saddam is another guy we gave TONS of money to, in order to secure oil contract. It's easy for President Bush to say that he committed all kinds of atrocities against people (which is 100% true) while ignoring the fact that we gave him the weapons to do it with, to fight Iran. He just happened to save some weapons and used them to gas and kill the opposing faction of Kurds in the north that wouldn't accept his rule and now have cabinet posts and all kinds of goodies in the new Iraqi Congress.
And we think that nobody's gonna get pissed off cuz of this? While it's not entirely the case that the US is their only enemy, it's not like the US is any friend of the Muslim people of these countries. And that's where some of this stems from.
Now the rest of being that fvcking crazy well -- I don't know, and I don't want to know. I just don't want to see it any more, because taking children hostage in a school is more fvcked up than I can even think about. In fact... I'm gonna stop here, because I'm hungry and I don't want to upset my stomach.
Ciao.