I swore up and down that I'd never have a long commute (even on ATOT). But then a job came along with enough salary bump to make the long commute worth it.
My perfect answer doesn't fit into your poll. I really want enough luxury to make the long drive pleasant, but a fuel sipper since I'm cheap. Sadly, no car really fits that bill. Apparently some luxury features and fuel efficiency don't go together in the minds of automobile manufacturers.
I got as close as I could: a Camry XLE hybrid. I get 36 MPG at 79 MPH, about the same as my old Civic. But, it has comfortable, heated leather seats, a decent ride (far better on snow/ice than the Civic which is important to me when commuting at interstate speeds), and a good enough sound system. Not really luxury, but it isn't bottom of the barrel either and the fuel economy is certainly good enough.