There's a trick here. If you want to order more than one, just place one in your cart to start. Then, on the cart page that comes up, scroll down to the ACCESSORIES section below. You'll see the same item listed at $8.95. Order your extras from this section.
Shipping is a pain, but not terrible. Shipping 2 from California to the southeast was $9.00, making the delivered cost $14 each. Not bad, considering the regular stores want $40 for a CD binder this size.