Critique my photoshop

[ultimatebob]

The almost neon green grass is too bright, and the shadow coming off of the guy is too harsh. Fix those two, and it won't look like an obvious "Photochop" anymore.

By removing the girl, you also removed the most interesting part of the picture... but maybe that's what you were going for. Wadda I know.

 

[Saint Nick]

Blur the shadow, make sure you know where the light is really coming from. Also maybe change the opacity of the shadow to make it less intense. Try maybe at 50% and go from there.

Try those and repost...

 

[hanoverphist]

Originally posted by: Mr Pickles


Nice work removing the girl. I wouldn't be able to tell she existed in the original.

except for the fact that the wall is now blocking the sidewalk...

 

[Modelworks]

Saturation too high, shadows are the wrong direction, as mentioned above - sidewalk is blocked by wall.
The angle of the wall was changed, obvious mirror from other side.
Trying to make the grass look perfect actually helps make it look like it's photoshop.
Dirt on things actually helps with realism.

 

[GodlessAstronomer]

Originally posted by: hanoverphist

Originally posted by: Mr Pickles


Nice work removing the girl. I wouldn't be able to tell she existed in the original.

except for the fact that the wall is now blocking the sidewalk...

Haha I didn't notice that, nice catch :thumbsup:

Originally posted by: Nik

Originally posted by: Syringer
Feel free to try and top it..I'd like to see what someone who really knows the program can do with it..

You suck with Photoshop. (but good try )

WTF? Apart from the orange, every single one of those looks like a pile of shit. So what if it takes immense skill to do that stuff if your piece of "art" is going to look so crappy at the end. Jesus.

 

[pcslookout]

Not good at all.

 

[hans030390]

Since you had to replace one of the pillar...things...on the right side to cover up the girl, you messed with the trees. There's a noticeable square of space that does not match.