Hate to be the wet blanket but its the same thing over and over, "we want TRUE PVP" but 99.99999999% who ask for that want it ONLY if they can win, and in TRUE PVP good players win the rest do not, so they all leave (Shadowbane has been mentioned here before). Anything that resembles True PvP is dead in a very short time. A few play it and dominate and the sheep get tired of dying over and over and leave. The games have short staying power as people who all "wanted" it come and play, see they cant match the elite players and leave and say it has some issues they don't like (namely they lack the skills to be competitive).
True PvP wont work, it never will for this reason alone. You need to keep a player base and unless you can compete people dont play. Love it or hate it WOW has one thing going, anybody (even the least of ability) can do pretty much anything.
But I am all for one making it, maybe this will be the one? I am not good enough to play against great PvP people, but ti would be fun to watch.
True PvP wont work, it never will for this reason alone. You need to keep a player base and unless you can compete people dont play. Love it or hate it WOW has one thing going, anybody (even the least of ability) can do pretty much anything.
But I am all for one making it, maybe this will be the one? I am not good enough to play against great PvP people, but ti would be fun to watch.