Since an, admitted, Comcast rep is on the post I have a question.
"If I call in asking for a retention specialist, instead of being directed to one, does the retention specialist know?"
The reason I wonder is because I, obviously, look a little more 'cheap' if I am asking for the retention guy, instead of being directed. So I didn't know if the rep informs the Specialist or just hits the transfer button.
Note: I'm in the Aurora IL area and for 25 months I've only paid full price like 4 months. As the OP said it's YMMV, but a simple 10 minute phone call every 6 months or so has saved me $25-$35 a month for 20+ months. Heck the last time I played the game I had the audacity to ask the retention specialist, who had already given me 1/2 off for 6 months on HSI, and I quote:
"So is there anything else I can get deal wise?"
She responded with 'Oh, well how about a free digital movie channel for 6 months?'
So I got all 10 HBO channels for free for 6 months. *shrug* Call them, it doesn't hurt, and you can apply the $100+ in savings to the 2005 or 2405 you know you are getting from Dell anyway.