If I hadn't already bought a Plextor 712 at the end of October, I might be all over this. It's pretty new to have many reviews, but run a google on it anyway - AOpen "DUW1608/ARR" review - and variants. The one review I found didn't give very high marks. But firmware updates might fix at least some of the problems. In any case, it is hard to tell from the review whether the reviewer used recommended media or just whatever he had on hand. At least initially (early firmware revs) one wants to go by the recommended media lists.
.bh.
p.s. There is a very new firmware update for this drive. (12/20/04). So any drive bought now probably won't have this rev. Need to update right away.
.b.h