Mine failed from Amazon in one week, started blue screening windows Vista, then had issues on bootup, never gave a SMART error, but would not pass Seatools diagnostic and just reported an error code and told me to contact warranty department. Seagate replaced it quickly but I was out another $5 to ship back to Seagate. Amazon packing was horrible, the drive was just loose in a larger box. Seagate sent back the refurb drive with 3 inch dense foam all the way around.
One of the rare times I didn't check newegg reviews before purchasing. The drive has a terrible reputation. The replacement from Seagate is fine, but the hassle ruins the deal.