This game is indisputably much better with a controller in my opinion. The K&M implementation is totally wonky in comparison. I tried K&M after the patch supposedly improved it, but it still sucked.
Anyway, so far I'm having a blast playing the game. I'm nowhere near finished with it, and there's just so much more stuff I have to do. I played it for about 8 hours each day since Friday, as my wife and kids were out of town and I was off from work..
Right now, I'd rate it about a 9/10, just on the entertainment factor alone. It's been a long time since a game has managed to captivate me like this..
One thing I find amusing, is Bioware's preoccupation with political correctness and gender equality in their games. I wouldn't be surprised if they made a list of how many characters they would make male, female, gay, straight, bisexual, black, white etcetera to appear as equable as possible. I noticed that Hawke in DAI is male, but the Hero(ine) of Ferelden was a woman..
I have no issue with it, I just think it's funny. I would never trust them to do a game based on a proper dark fantasy setting like GRRM's Westeros however.
But I would trust CDPR. The World of the Witcher to me is much darker and more believable than Bioware's Thedas..