Edy's Double Fudge Brownie and Berry Rainbow Sherbet for me.
FWIW Stop and Shop has the deal for Edy's $1.79 each, but limit two. So if you want to get the $4 coupon you need to buy two of something else to go with it. They had the same deal about 6 months ago with a limit of 4 on the Edy's. I stopped in a few times and wound up getting 12 half gallons of Edy's for something like $8