It kind of made sense once you realize that the GOP has become the party of conspiracy theorists, especially when it comes to Covid. And it seems Musk went right down that rabbit hole. This is literally how conspiracy theorists think - “If I can prove one thing wrong, then EVERYTHING is wrong!” If Fauci says one thing wrong (for example: the mask statement they ran with a couple years ago), then everything we have been told about Covid by Fauci is a lie.
It’s like how they spend years obsessing over minute details of things like shadows in photos of the Moon landings, because if they can show that one shadow is “off" or "wrong", then the whole Moon landing was faked.
What I see with discussions of the “lab release” conspiracy. If anyone with actual expertise and knowledge says, “Well, if it was released by a lab, we’d expect to see these characteristics. However, we don’t see those characteristics, so it probably wasn’t released by a lab”. The mere fact that the theory was being discussed, even if it was immediately dismissed by experts, is proof that “they knew it came from a lab and are lying about it!!!”
It makes conspiracy theories attractive because once you have gone down the rabbit hole, you can feel like you know what’s going on by manufacturing or believing in a simple, childish, factually unconstrained narrative. The lie that ‘it’s all simple’ is emotionally appealing to those who prefer a life lived without effort and critical thinking skills. It requires no work. All you have to do is accept what the conspiracy monger tells you. And a heaping helping of self-serving delusion and flattery in every ‘Only WE know the truth of it!’ message.