Originally posted by: Riverhound777
Originally posted by: Sukhoi
Originally posted by: Riverhound777
Is it bad to replace a meal with a protein shake? Many mornings I don't have time to make a decent breakfast, so I just have a shake. I assume it is better than nothing. My shake includes a cup of 2% milk, a heaping scoop of Optimum 100% whey double choc, and a banana blended.
I am also pretty hungry when I get off work around 5:30 so I have a shake then so I don't eat dinner too early. I usually work out after having this shake, then eat dinner a few hours later. I know i'm not getting the 1g/lb of my weight, but I figure it is better than nothing.
I currently am 6'1 and weigh 175 pounds, do I really need to take 175g of protein in a day? The only time I have done that was when I had a shake for breakfast(40g), 20g in my lunch burritos, shake after work(40g), chicken breast for dinner with a glass of milk(40g), and another shake before bed(40g). That came out to 180g and I was really full. I can't see myself doing that daily.
What's your goal?
To gain strength and be fit, my weight doesn't really concern me. I got my first desk job after college about a year and a half ago and have gained about 15 pounds since. Starting about 2 months ago I began working out, running, and eating better along with taking protein. So far my weight has stayed the same at 175, but I have made pretty good gains in my lifting(I have pretty much stopped running sadly, but I was making gains there too) and I think I have probably replaced a good 5-10 pounds of fat with muscle. I still have a ways to go to be as fit as I would like.
I know I should be doing cardio, but I just don't have the time or the drive with it being dark when I get off work. I have a weight bench at home so I don't have a gym membership. But I do have a few roommates who I have been working out with, so that helps a lot.
You need cardio. But really for doing what you are you don't necessarily need quite that much protein. It isn't going to hurt you but it may not be all that beneficial either. Remember when you have a protein shake as a meal replacement you're just using the protein for energy. It's not helping your muscles. You need to eat full meals and then have protein in addition to that.