To get some context here we are talking about just over a thousand people out of the three hundred and something million that are US passport holders.
A better comparison would be 1131 out of the 6 million living abroad. Still a tiny percentage but the 600% increase over previous years is definitely noteworthy
People come up with spectacularly complex schemes to avoid taxes and then get pissed because explaining their schemes takes expert time and effort? I can't say I feel much pain on their behalf.
So you think all six million people living abroad are coming up with complex tax schemes? Really the result is punishing a large group for what a minority of people do.
LOL what a bunch of whiners. I feel for the "regular" or "innocent" people that have to fill out extra tax forms (first world problems), but perhaps those unnecessarily affected should complain to tax dodgers for dodging taxes instead of the group that is trying to correct things and prevent tax dodging...
First - being an American and working abroad is already a very difficult tax situation. I have looked very seriously at doing so and the tax law is, as Fern said, difficult, complex with a variety of vague\incomplete recommendations by the IRS. It would be one thing if the information was clear and straight forward but its not. Not even close.
Besides, this is more than just 'filling out extra forms' - this is also a power grab by the IRS against foreign institutions:
"require all financial institutions around the world to report directly to the US Internal Revenue Service (IRS) all the assets and incomes of any US citizens with $50,000 (£31,000) on their books." regardless of the country's own laws. Then we threaten with fines or locking them out of American business.
Then there is the debate on whether the Treasury Dept actually has legal authority to offer reciprocity on data sharing which may go against already agreed to contracts and state\local laws. Several lawsuits have already been filed regarding this
Already banks world wide are shying away from dealing with Americans. Barriers to entry are raised so that only accounts they deem 'worthwhile' are allowed. Both Barclays and HSBC raised the minimums for their international accounts and I believe this is a common trend. So the common US worker abroad is punished while the rich suffer little consequence from these actions
The best part of all this though:
Everything depends on
ALL other major banking countries complying with our demands. What happens if a major one (or a new player) doesn't? Well, all the 'rich, fat cats' this was designed to catch just transfer their money to that country while all the other honest, hard working Americans working in other countries get fucked over.