Originally posted by: alkemyst
Originally posted by: Vonkhan
alkemyst:
1. The lease allows pets
2. Both my dogs are mentioned on the lease
3. My gf is not mentioned on the lease
4. I'm the only on on the lease
Then that was why he wanted your g/f out of the apartment and why he more than likely was raising your rent.
Your g/f getting defiant with him set this stage.
Since she was staying there against the lease, she should have STFU and simply told the landlord she would let you know. Then you could have hashed it out with him.
Your neighbor did not have those dogs on his lease. Since now you have mentioned it was a part of the lease, he would have needed that also.
You should have gave your neighbor a key and let him come in to take care of the dogs.
The pissing part is your word vs his. It's sort of unlikely a landlord is going to fuck up his own place though...not saying it's not possible.
Getting you beat up over something as simple as throwing your ass out for having uncontracted tenants living there as well as a future third tenant would have been a lot more simple.
You also seem to mention a lot of details most would not think would be needed...you know the officer had a single stripe but didn't notice his nametag that should have stated his rank nor thought to just ask who he was (which should have gotten you a Capt..., Sarge..., Lt...., etc).
Your play by play of your assault seems odd too. I have been in fights and I really couldn't do a play by play of what I threw nor what was thrown at me most of the time...esp in a surprise situation.
You also saying he was perfectly a great LL then 'suddenly' now some kind of psycho leaves a lot to question, but just looking at you wanting to crack his head for mouthing off to the chick you had living there off the lease shows more against you than for you especially in about 75% of your posts you mention wanting to hurt him rather than really wanting a solution.
If you are in the right, this should be a simple to prove case. Being it's an apartment there should be witnesses other than just you and your friend.
Personally I'd just have moved on long ago.