rockhard - I posted this in your other thread but you asked the same question of me here so here it is:
I've had great fun and success with my Intel OC. My first try with the Gigabyte board was a pain but that's not too unusual in a cutting-edge situation like this. Hell, I got my 1.8A on January 28th, one week after it was released, I messed with the 8IXRP for a few days, learned a few things and RMA'd the board. I got a full refund so I wasn't out any money and I got an Asus P4B266 to replace it . Tried again with this board and have had a lot of fun with it.
I LOVE this P4 compared to my AMD Tbird. I've been an AMD guy for a while now, but I've always had a difficult time with all the fan noise you have to put up with to cool these beetches off. I've spent a lot of time/money on various HSF's, Panaflos by the butt-load, reostats, etc. It's also a little disconcerting to know that if any of your CPU cooling burps even a little bit, your chip is going to go up in smoke!
The Northwood on the other hand, runs cool as a cucumber with the standard VERY quiet retail HSF and a few quiet case fans. You also don't have to worry about the chip melting down if something goes wrong with your cooling setup. It will just throttle back to save itself. Here's a real wild idea that AMD should think about looking at.
Another great thing about this Intel setup is that it absolutely stable right out of the box. No VIA crap to worry about, no new chipset drivers released by Intel everytime the wind changes direction. Just plug the processor into the MoBo, clip on the very quiet and very efficient retail HSF (without having your heart in your throat wondering if you're going to crack your core), load your OS and you're ready to rock.
It's fun to OC, but so what if you can only get 1.8Ghz? you've got a box that's as quick as an AMD 1800+ for about the same money, that runs way cooler, needs less fans, and won't self-destruct if something goes wrong with your HSF, and is completely stable right out of the box. I'd say hang in there. I'd ditch the Gigabyte and get (at least) an Asus P4B266-C, if not the full P4B266. Unless you've got a bum chip you should be able to get at least 2.1Ghz with this setup.