Good Modular Power Supply?

[GalvanizedYankee]

http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/other/display/foxconn-hiper_6.html

http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/other/display/foxconn-hiper_9.html[/quote]

Thank you Howard but now my tummy hurts.
The unit did NOT test well and the soldering looks like some kind of hap-hazzard rework.
To put it in blue collar terms, pure unadultrated crap.


...Galvanized

 

[Mem]

Thank you Howard but now my tummy hurts.
The unit did NOT test well and the soldering looks like some kind of hap-hazzard rework.
To put it in blue collar terms, pure unadultrated crap.

One bad review?Hmmm I can find you bad reviews of Enermax etc., does not mean they are bad ,Howard does not like Hiper PSUs from previous posts I have seen,I 'm actually using one and can tell you they are fine,also approved for Nvidia SLI and Hiper company work in partnership with AMD,also they have a new version out for last few months too.

I could post 20+ great review links of Hiper type R 580w,but just take my word for it they are good PSUs.

If you don't believe me or the many good reviews try asking other AT members that actually own a Hiper PSU,from what I have seen posted by them, they are happy too.



Review by Tom's Hardware

We were pleasantly surprised by manufacturer Hiper: They fixed all their earlier failings from our live test. Today, they offer solid power supplies that follow the specifications and operate without malfunction. They must still improve on their efficiency ratings, however.

If we awarded a prize for design, Hiper would walk away with it hands-down with its Type R power supply. This power supply, with its cable management based on modular avionics-style connectors, will be sure to raise the pulse of any case modder.

DATED FEB 06.

 

[GalvanizedYankee]

Quite frankly Mem, I'll pass on just about all rebranded PSUs.

Did you even look at the linked pic from Xbit Labs?? Xbit is a VG review site
that doesn't offer Kick-Ass-Awards
Open your Hyper and have a look-see at the bottom of the pcb


...Galvanized

 

[Mem]

Quite frankly Mem, I'll pass on just about all rebranded PSUs.

Did you even look at the linked pic from Xbit Labs?? Xbit is a VG review site
that doesn't offer Kick-Ass-Awards
Open your Hyper and have a look-see at the bottom of the pcb

I have seen that review before,as I said I have seen bad reviews of Enermax and even Seasonic PSUs from other sites(but we know they are still good PSUs) ,I based my experience on everyday use with my Hiper PSU ,rock solid,that review is bit dated now too.Even in Overclocking UK forums they have had good feedback..

Mine is about 6 months old now(got it in Nov 05).Would I buy another Hiper PSU,yep I would for sure.I'm not saying they are the best period, but a good PSU.

 

[Operandi]

Originally posted by: Mem

Quite frankly Mem, I'll pass on just about all rebranded PSUs.

Did you even look at the linked pic from Xbit Labs?? Xbit is a VG review site
that doesn't offer Kick-Ass-Awards
Open your Hyper and have a look-see at the bottom of the pcb

I have seen that review before,as I said I have seen bad reviews of Enermax and even Seasonic PSUs from other sites(but we know they are still good PSUs) ,I based my experience on everyday use with my Hiper PSU ,rock solid,that review is bit dated now too.Even in Overclocking UK forums they have had good feedback..

Mine is about 6 months old now(got it in Nov 05).Would I buy another Hiper PSU,yep I would for sure.I'm not saying they are the best period, but a good PSU.

The point here is Xbit is one of about 3-4 web sites that dose proper PSU reviews; the rest don't count for anything and have no business doing reviews in the first place.

If you focus on the good reviews that feature proper tests you?ll see that the Hiper units come out about average at best and offer nothing to support their $100+ price tag.

 

[LOUISSSSS]

i agree, other websites that test dont actually look at the quality of the psu, which can only be seen on the inside. other websites just test for a few hours then move on. of course any psu will power your system for a few hours.

 

[Howard]

Originally posted by: JEDIYoda

Originally posted by: Howard

Originally posted by: JEDIYoda

Originally posted by: n7

Originally posted by: LOUISSSSS
never owned a modular psu but can tell you that hiper type R psus are crap

Ignorance is bliss.

Seriously, have you ever posted anything helpful or positive? :roll:

LOUISSSS opinions are based on nothing; if there was any truth to them he would also post supporting links.....

http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/other/display/foxconn-hiper_6.html

http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/other/display/foxconn-hiper_9.html

So what did you prove?

All the Hiper type R series modular PSU`s have gotten good reviews!!!

Just being you I guess huh??

SilenX stuff can get good reviews too. What does that prove?

 

[Howard]

Originally posted by: Mem

Thank you Howard but now my tummy hurts.
The unit did NOT test well and the soldering looks like some kind of hap-hazzard rework.
To put it in blue collar terms, pure unadultrated crap.

Howard does not like Hiper PSUs from previous posts I have seen,

Not without a reason. I just don't think it's a good choice because there are other PSUs that are way superior in build quality that offer similar features at the same or lower cost (save for aesthetics).

You never responded to my last post in that thread, so does that mean you chose to ignore my valid points, or did you just not see it?

 

[Mem]

You never responded to my last post in that thread, so does that mean you chose to ignore my valid points, or did you just not see it?

I was going to reply but can see you want to start some sort of argument/debate so what is the point?...You have your opinion,and I have mine that is based on actually using one which is better then any 1000 words can say,lets just leave it at that.

 

[hondaf17]

Wow, thanks for all the input/advice guys - didn't mean to get a big debate going!

I'll check out everyone's suggestions but will probably end up going wtih the OCZ modstream or Enermax Liberty.

 

[JEDIYoda]

Originally posted by: GalvanizedYankee
Quite frankly Mem, I'll pass on just about all rebranded PSUs.

Did you even look at the linked pic from Xbit Labs?? Xbit is a VG review site
that doesn't offer Kick-Ass-Awards
Open your Hyper and have a look-see at the bottom of the pcb


...Galvanized

DOuble talk at its best!!
There is nothing at all wrong with rebranded PSU`s.......
The facts simply don`t substatiate that staement!

Unless its a personnal opinion then we are forced to respect your opinion!!

 

[Howard]

Originally posted by: JEDIYoda

Originally posted by: GalvanizedYankee
Quite frankly Mem, I'll pass on just about all rebranded PSUs.

Did you even look at the linked pic from Xbit Labs?? Xbit is a VG review site
that doesn't offer Kick-Ass-Awards
Open your Hyper and have a look-see at the bottom of the pcb


...Galvanized

DOuble talk at its best!!
There is nothing at all wrong with rebranded PSU`s.......
The facts simply don`t substatiate that staement!

Unless its a personnal opinion then we are forced to respect your opinion!!

Personal opinion garners little of my respect (unless backed by fact). You probably knew how I felt already, though.

 

[nycdude]

Originally posted by: CraKaJaX
I've had my OCZ Modstream 520W since December of 04 without any problems. Haven't had any experience with any other modular PSU's... but for OCZ = :thumbsup:

my ocz has been chugging along great. The Enermax Liberty looks sweet too.

 

[Rubycon]

Originally posted by: http://tomshardware.co.uk/2006/02/07/5_power_supplies_get_the_full_juice_treatment_uk/page19.html

If we awarded a prize for design, Hiper would walk away with it hands-down with its Type R power supply. This power supply, with its cable management based on modular avionics-style connectors, will be sure to raise the pulse of any case modder.

ROFL, they really believe those connectors are used in avionics equipment? They are actually mic connectors for radio equipment. I'm not even sure they are designed to carry more than a few amps at most. I will have to dig through the Amphenol catalog and see.

 

[JEDIYoda]

Originally posted by: MS Dawn

Originally posted by: http://tomshardware.co.uk/2006/02/07/5_power_supplies_get_the_full_juice_treatment_uk/page19.html

If we awarded a prize for design, Hiper would walk away with it hands-down with its Type R power supply. This power supply, with its cable management based on modular avionics-style connectors, will be sure to raise the pulse of any case modder.

ROFL, they really believe those connectors are used in avionics equipment? They are actually mic connectors for radio equipment. I'm not even sure they are designed to carry more than a few amps at most. I will have to dig through the Amphenol catalog and see.

There website says-- Power Delivery:
Aviation Type heavy duty Enamel Modular Connector (Patent Pending)

http://images.search.yahoo.com/search/i...FP-tab-web-t342&toggle=1&cop=&ei=UTF-8

 

[Rubycon]

They're not though.

Our consultant has years experience in the aerospace trade and laughs at such assertion. Things people will believe in out of industry trades to make a sale when they see something that makes them go hmmmmm.

 

[JEDIYoda]

Originally posted by: MS Dawn
They're not though.

Our consultant has years experience in the aerospace trade and laughs at such assertion. Things people will believe in out of industry trades to make a sale when they see something that makes them go hmmmmm.

Your consultant is obviously a figment of your imagination!
I talked to local airdraft mecahanics who say they hasve seen similar type connectors ....
so whose consultant is right??

plus if you read closely you will see the key word highlighted...
Aviation Type heavy duty Enamel Modular Connector

 

[Rubycon]

Originally posted by: JEDIYoda

Originally posted by: MS Dawn
They're not though.

Our consultant has years experience in the aerospace trade and laughs at such assertion. Things people will believe in out of industry trades to make a sale when they see something that makes them go hmmmmm.

Your consultant is obviously a figment of your imagination!
I talked to local airdraft mecahanics who say they hasve seen similar type connectors ....
so whose consultant is right??

plus if you read closely you will see the key word highlighted...
Aviation Type heavy duty Enamel Modular Connector

Anyways, type/style is a marketing term. Just the ferrule ring cost more than that cheap chinese made power supply. Wonder why? Those avionics connectors have DOZENS of positions (conductors) and are made of the highest quality conductors on both male and female ends. The power supply connectors are low grade connectors used for communications gear aka microphone connectors for radio gear.

What a real avionics type connection looks like

What a mic connector looks like

Yes and this consultant USED to post here and I'm starting to see why, keyword USED tol. :roll: I love how everyone here THINKS they're a freaking EE with YEARS of experience. Granted I'm not but I have lots of hands on experience with folks that ARE and thus learn right from wrong. Real people are much better teachers than Google.

What concerns me more about this is the MIS APPLICATION of this product (mic connector) for a power supply. One of the reasons for going multi-rail is to reduce the current loading but even at 10+ AMPERES at 12VDC that is still very, very high for a MICROPHONE connector! At least the original MOLEX design was designed for this kind of power.