Well, I went ahead and ordered the leather one. I know it probably won't be the greatest chair in the world (one of my roomies has a $1000+ chair... aeron? something like that? Man, I could sleep in his chair. Reminded me of Picard's command chair on the enterprise with all the little knobs, options and stuff)...
Oops. Sorry... rambling there.
Anyways, Office Depot's only a block and a half from my house, so if it sucks, I'll just bring it back. I'll be picking it up tonight after work, so I'll post something afterwards.