I took a hybrid approach to what you did. I made sure to invest enough to get the match (and a little more) but put most of my extra money into paying off debt (interest rates were much higher then - running 7% on mortgages). I was roasted at the time (by many on this forum) but don't regret it for a second. Having my home (all debt actually) paid off at the age of 37 (over 9 years now) has been wonderful. Top it off with the luck that the market tanked during that period allowing me to put more of my previous mortgage money into funds allowing it to grow pretty quickly.
No complaints at this point on that decision.
Also, what are the thoughts on having X times salary at ages throughout life? I just read an article that said that you should have 1X salary in retirement at 35, 3X salary at 45, 5X salary at 55 and 8 times salary at 67 if you want to retire with 85% of your salary for 25 years of retirement. That seems somewhat sensible to me.
http://www.boston.com/businessupdat...-retirement/0XyV8OuLWyT8ZF4RCeq6xN/story.html