Ok, so the vue is looking more and more better....
Basically by the time I dump my Tivo subscription, cable card, digital boxes and Time warner fees...I'm getting it for "free". I'd save about $30 a month over what I'm paying now, get 10x the number of stations and bit more freedom to watch it in other parts of the home/remotely with ipads.
I like Vue, but I've had a few issues with it. My two biggest are repeating live TV and sync issue. So like when watching live TV sometimes it will just randomly replay a few seconds over again. And with the sync issues, on some channels the audio won't be in sync with the video. My last live TV watch was the NBA draft and the audio was a good .5 second behind the video. Drove me nuts. I've seen some other complaints about it, so hopefully it gets fixed soon.