Originally posted by: StWendeler
Originally posted by: slots
I wanted to get this monitor, but is it really as good as advertised?
Claiming that it responds at 8ms could be a marketing ploy, this just seems to be too good to be true for the price.
Also, i have not seen this monitor reviewed by any independent testers (other than user reviews) sd wendelers review has not impressed me into a purchase either.
I might just buy a quality CRT, these 19IN LCD's are pretty much in their infancy.
Here's an independent review. You'll see that this monitor got highest rating from these folks, but then didn't get mentioned in the conclusion. From what I understand, they reviewed this AFTER they did the full article.
http://behardware.com/articles/534/page1.html
Go to Page 4 for the Hyundai review. May want to considerr some of the others as well, but you won't get near this price for this feature set (ergonomics, response time, etc). I've downloaded the trial pivot pro software (which I believe is bundled with higher end samsungs) and it works fine with this. Question is whether it's worht the $40. Yeah, it's pretty nifty... but how often will I use? I'll know by the time the 30day trial is up.
I think the 8ms is over-hyped, too. but this is the same for every manufacturer. BTW, this panel is the same one that's in the new Samsung 915N (announced at CES just a couple of weeks ago). I've seen tests on 12ms and 16ms panels that show that avg response time is much higher, but they can hit a 16ms response time under certain conditions. Note also that in order to get this response time, you sacrifice viewing angles and (supposedly) color clarity. Notice that the BeHardware review has delta tracking of the colors and it does pretty well (same as samsung, obviously).
Regardless, i've seen no ghosting in fps... however, iit's not as good as a CRT (no LCD will be - CRTs have response times under 2ms.)
I did see the twinkling effect when booting up a vid game with black startup screen... it wasn't really noticeable, but I could see how a reviewer would have probs with it. I viewed Two Towers using this monitor and it looked good - no twinkling/zero ghosting. I tried to get to dark scenes to see black levels, twinkling, etc...everything looked great.