I love these types of posts. Let's see, Kraft American Cheese ingredients:
MILK, WHEY, MILK PROTEIN CONCENTRATE, MILKFAT, CONTAINS LESS THAN 2% OF CALCIUM PHOSPHATE, SALT, SODIUM CITRATE, WHEY PROTEIN CONCENTRATE, SODIUM PHOSPHATE, SORBIC ACID AS A PRESERVATIVE, CHEESE CULTURE, ENZYMES, ANNATTO AND PAPRIKA EXTRACT (COLOR), VITAMIN D3.
Clearfield White American Cheese Ingredients:
Cultured Milk, Water, Cream, Salt, Sodium Phosphate, Lactic Acid, Artificial Color, Enzymes.
Now, looking at the list, it could be reasonably concluded that "OMG, Kraft American Cheese is crap compared to Clearfield. It's not even real cheese!" Well, let's look a little further, shall we.
Common ingredients between the two:
Kraft's Milk and Cheese Cultures = Clearfields Cultured Milk (same thing, stated differently)
Milkfat = Cream
Salt
Sodium Phosphate
Enzymes
That leaves a few non-shared ingredients, so this is where the gap between real cheese and cheese-like product begins...or so we are led to believe.
First, Kraft uses natural coloring from Annatto and Paprika seeds, while Clearfield uses "artificial coloring", whatever that is.
Clearfield uses Lactid Acid as a food preservative, while Kraft uses Sorbic Acid and Sodium Citrate (BTW, Kraft just announced last month that they are removing food preservatives, so expect your Kraft Singles not to last as long).
Kraft adds Whey and Whey Protein Concentrate - proteins, whippty do. Hell, some folks drink whey protein shakes.
Kraft adds Calcium Phosphate as a way to add calcium to it's product and reduce acidity. Nothing wrong with Calcium phosphate.
Kraft adds Sodium Phosphate as an emulsifier. Again, nothing wrong with Sodium Phosphate and a hell of a lot of foods use it.
So, there you are, Kraft has 4 ingredients that Clearfield does not contain and not one of them is an issue.
So, why is Kraft American Cheese considered a "cheeselike" product, while Clearfield is a cheese?