We tried a big amnesty in the 80's for several million ILLEGALS and we are planing to do another BIGGER one for 11 million ILLEGALS or more but this time, it will "work" because of reason?
Because it worked last time. The vast majority of them became legal productive tax paying citizens of the United States. That is what you say you want. That is how you accomplish it. Why are you so against doing what works?
And please start referring to illegal immigrants as what they are. Illegal.
Because they are not. That is just a flat out lie by your part. They are, at best, people suspected of committing a misdemeanor. You probably committed a similar crime on your morning commute to work this morning.
It is important to remember that a person is not 'Illegal'. They might have committed a crime, but the people themselves are not illegal.
I remember the promise of the big amnesty in the 80's (4 to 5 million of ILLEGALS IIRC) that we would not have more ILLEGALs because of this and that and so and so (too many to list). Years later and we have even more ILLEGALS. You call that as "working"?
Your logic is flawed. If we gave amnesty to 4 to 5 million people, and we had basically no chance at deporting the majority of those people, so then there are 4 to 5 million fewer than they would be otherwise. That is how math works. You can point to no evidence at all that the amnesty lead to more unlawful immigration, so the only proper conclusions is that it either reduced the number by 4-5 million, or it had an unknown effect.
If amnesty was working so great, then why no country on Earth would do that?
Other countries are doing it. That little lie is also a complete fantasy by the right wing conspiracy factory. Just a quick search finds that Brazil, Spain, and Jamaica have all offered amnesty for unlawful immigrants.
I want everyone to follow immigration rules and laws equally.
Then we should change the laws to something that works. If you have more people breaking the law then following it something is wrong with the law not the people.
I sure hope you never speed, or double park, or litter. Those are all similar crimes. That would make you an ILLEGAL too.