Originally posted by: Moonbeam
Originally posted by: 3chordcharlie
Originally posted by: lyssword
I will not comment on evolution or ID+creationism, but the pure usage of put-downs by "evolution" camp seem to be not in a spirit of debate but simple dirty fighting. Please, comments like "dumbshit, idiot, retard, monkey, laughable, stupid, pure BS, bullshit, etc.." ( I don't have the time to find all of the words used) doesn't help get your point of view across to the "other camp". TY
I agree, it's very frustrating trying to get people to stop repeating the lies they've swallowed.
Everytime one of these threads becomes active, someone claims that 'evolution can't be right' and starts asking for 'transitional fossils' and all sorts of crap like that, thinking they have really shown science where they can stick it.
Then when one of us patiently explains that they are very, very wrong, and backs that up with both fossil and biological evidence, the person either responds with 'yeah but I don't believe that' or just runs away.
So when someone gets frustrated by an ID proponent, especially one who they know was around 'last time' this discussion was had, I find it fairly easy to empathize.
Well there is a problem here, I think:
We know that only people who have been introduced to religious indoctrination previously and at a younger age then the awakening of the processes of reasoning and scientific logic in early adulthood posses an inner motivation to struggle against the notions of Darwin. From the fact that they mostly come from a subculture, and a sub-religious culture at that, tells us that they are bigots.
A bigot is simply a person who has a prior irrational religious belief that pops up out of the unconscious to tell him or her what is right or wrong autonomously, as in robot fashion. Evolution is wrong because the Bible says so and it is the word of God.
So no matter what argument you bring in evolution's favor, that argument must be wrong because the entire ego structure of the bigot, his whole false notion of his worthiness as a Christian and beloved of God, rests on the assumption of that truth.
So when you ask a fundamentalist Christian to have an unbiased look at evolution you are asking him to die, to experience the feelings of worthlessness his religious faith is there to mask. Worse still, the false feelings of worth that he does feel, while totally false at their root, are emotionally correspondent in many ways to how people should feel.
Self respect is a natural condition of man, an inalienable truth as it were. And respect leads to all sorts of natural virtues. So you can get a situation where you may be correctly arguing the truth of evolution with a person whose Being Morality is greater than your own and the self-evidence of that in his or her eyes will weight heavily against you.
Calling him or her a dumb ass, for example, can be one of those things. His religion usually includes the command to love you and to treat you as he or she would like to be treated. You may have the superior argument but he or she the superior manners. Where could such dumbassed, I mean poor manners come from:
The transformation of youth into adulthood is in part about the acquisition of self respect. But again because all people everywhere are infected with self hate as a condition of the fact of learning language that abstracts and creates concepts that don't exist, ie, the notion that you are worthless, and then applies them to children, everybody has created a false self. For the religious person it is his religious illusions and for others it is other things.
The young man or woman who grows to understand that the religious bs he was fed as a child is crap becomes very proud of his new capacity for logical thinking. Look at me, I am BS free. Well, not really because you are still stuck with your miserable pinhead ego. For the logical thinking type science can become his religion. Science is the power of light that cast aside superstition and illusions. Of course it never gets around to self examination, one of the duties of the religious.
So the secular type has built his self respect on the powers of the mind to scientifically discover truth. This is his ego substitute for real self respect. It has the profound power to convince because it is logical. Voilà, I am now a somebody because I am a scientist. This is his religion because it functions exactly the same.
OK, so along comes this nut case Christian who will not bow down to you God, Mr. Logic and you immediately feel the threat. If my God logic is false too then my life is also worthless. Well, yes, because it is the real truth of what you really do feel. You have erected your self respect on the external as other religious types do.
And it is this seeing yourself, this denial, in the Christian that is in you that causes you to be pissed off. You and he are the same and he is the ass you feel you are.
That is why we hate people who are different. We are different than we should be and we hate who we are. All who refuse to feel their own pain wish it on others.