I just did some searching on Google, because I wanted to see if anyone else was having these problems. Guess what? I've read numerous reports of my motherboard not being able to run Nvidia cards! I can't believe this! I'm calling up MSI as soon as I can.
If this turns out to be the problem that has been haunting me for almost three months and costing me time and money, I am so f*cking done with MSI and ATI. Never again will I buy any of their products.