Is psychiatry a false discipline?

[HAL9000]

lol..

Psychiatry is evil. Morals don't exist as all know, but it's an evil practice nonetheless. Medicine is about curing people and making them better, yet psychiatry is the odd one out. It was invented and still exists as a tool to punish people, especially those who are "normal". lol.. anybody with half a brain knows that normalcy is subjective, and frankly doesn't exist.

Psychiatry isn't evil.
Psychiatry doesn't punish people.

I'm ill, mentally ill. I need medication for my illness, the medical specialists who deal with this type of illness are psychiatrists, they prescribe me the medication I need.

Spend 20 minutes with someone in the middle of a psychotic break, or talk to someone who's bipolar or schizophrenic and then tell me mental illness doesn't exist.

 

[mammador]

Troll elsewhere, retard.

The salient points are true:

- Psychiatry is evil
- Medicine exists to cure, not penalise
- Morals don't exist, per modern thinking/values
- Psychiatry was invented as a tool to punish (read medical history)
- Normality is subjective

These are facts of life.

 

[mammador]

Psychiatry isn't evil.
Psychiatry doesn't punish people.

I'm ill, mentally ill. I need medication for my illness, the medical specialists who deal with this type of illness are psychiatrists, they prescribe me the medication I need.

Spend 20 minutes with someone in the middle of a psychotic break, or talk to someone who's bipolar or schizophrenic and then tell me mental illness doesn't exist.

Psychiatrists wish to punish people and control.

 

[OinkBoink]

lol.. an opinion cannot be "wrong" by definition.

Again, who are you to question me? You cite psychiatry, yet you people don't even understand basic social protocols.

Let's not get stuck on semantics here.

If you don't want people to cross question you, why post on a public forum ?

Yet again, what were you diagnosed with ?

 

[HAL9000]

Psychiatrists wish to punish people and control.

Are you just going to ignore the rest of my post as it disproves your point?

Psychiatrists are just doctors, they want to help people control their illnesses.

 

[mammador]

Let's not get stuck on semantics here.

If you don't want people to cross question you, why post on a public forum ?

Yet again, what were you diagnosed with ?

Cross question? You think some stranger has to answer your queries? I'm correct, you don't get social protocol. I'd imagine you "cross question" people in supermarkets or trains.

I don't trust psychiatric diagnoses, since it's a non-science. Normalcy is subjective, so nothing can be an "illness".

 

[mammador]

Are you just going to ignore the rest of my post as it disproves your point?

Psychiatrists are just doctors, they want to help people control their illnesses.

I disagree. Most of them are out to abuse people.

 

[happybelly]

Are you just going to ignore the rest of my post as it disproves your point?

Psychiatrists are just doctors, they want to help people control their illnesses.

It's pretty obvious after his reply to your valid personal experience that he should just be ignored at this point.

 

[HAL9000]

nm better point below.

 

[HAL9000]

I disagree. Most of them are out to abuse people.

What do you think about the fact that I am diagnosed with a mental illness and that psychiatrists help me regularly?

How much time have you spent in the care of a psychiatrist or mental health professional?

 

[HAL9000]

It's pretty obvious after his reply to your valid personal experience that he should just be ignored at this point.

Pretty obvious, true, but I'd like to hear what he thinks about my valid personal experience.

 

[mammador]

You're most likely the exception to the rule.

 

[HAL9000]

You're most likely the exception to the rule.

What about the millions of others who are diagnosed with bipolar disorder, cyclothymia, schizophrenia, autism etc etc etc etc

I know about 50 bipolar people who are all being cared for by an assortment of psychiatrists in and around my area, are they all the exceptions to the rule? Or do you just not know what you're talking about...

 

[happybelly]

You're most likely the exception to the rule.

So he's the only exception out of millions of people with similar conditions? Keep trolling.

 

[tcsenter]

Have you been to a psychiatrist ? If yes, what did he/she diagnose you with ?

They do always seem to give themselves away, eh?

 

[Capt Caveman]

The salient points are true:

- Psychiatry is evil
- Medicine exists to cure, not penalise
- Morals don't exist, per modern thinking/values
- Psychiatry was invented as a tool to punish (read medical history)
- Normality is subjective

These are facts of life.

Nope. But keep on trolling. You've been reported.

 

[Capt Caveman]

So he's the only exception out of millions of people with similar conditions? Keep trolling.

Don't know why people even try to reason with this troll. Just report him.

 

[TheVrolok]

Quite obvious the OP has an antipsychiatry agenda.

Psychiatry is a completely valid, evidence based, and definite field of medicine. To state otherwise is simply ignorance.

Might as well just quote myself from his nearly identical thread last September. Can we get this clown banned now?

 

[mammador]

Nope. But keep on trolling. You've been reported.

Nope? Kindly state how my self-evident points are not fact.

 

[HAL9000]

It is obvious from your posts that you do not wish to hear or consider other's opinions but came in here to promote wacky ideas of your own. That's trolling.
admin allisolm

Quote from your previous thread on this topic. May be worth re-reading.

 

[TheVrolok]

http://bbsimg.ngfiles.com/1/20529000/ngbbs4b36c461527bb.jpg

 

[HAL9000]

The salient points are true:

- Psychiatry is evil
- Morals don't exist

:hmm:

 

[mammador]

:hmm:

People are inconsistent and contradictory. It's the human way. And?

 

[HAL9000]

People are inconsistent and contradictory. It's the human way. And?

Psychiatry is a valid discipline, it diagnoses and helps people with mental illnesses.

 

[mammador]

As said, you are the exception to the rule.