is size 8 on a girl fat???

[zanejohnson]

capt caveman is the only person in this thread who is the typical "elbows too pointy" keyboard warrior...get over yourself dude, this is ATOT, nobody cares...

 

[hanoverphist]

and my ex was tiny.. she was like 120lbs and 5'9... you must be thinking of someone else...here's a pic of the ex... i dont have any full body pics, but her face and body are proportionate.. i think she was like a size 2 or 4 if i remember correctly.. she's almost sickly skinny looking...

nah, it was you. and that pic of her looks more like the pre kid days. mebbe it was the angle of the pics you posted way back when, but she didnt look that thin. dont get me wrong, i thought she was attractive either way, but i remember bigger neck and face.

 

[Capt Caveman]

capt caveman is the only person in this thread who is the typical "elbows too pointy" keyboard warrior...get over yourself dude, this is ATOT, nobody cares...

Some people have standards and then we have Zane Johnson. :biggrin:

 

[zanejohnson]

nah, it was you. and that pic of her looks more like the pre kid days. mebbe it was the angle of the pics you posted way back when, but she didnt look that thin. dont get me wrong, i thought she was attractive either way, but i remember bigger neck and face.

nah that pic really isn't that old, it was after kids... she kept her figure after both kids... she might actually be even hotter if that's possible after kids... it might have been like a preggo pic or something, that's the only time she ever had any weight to her at all.. i mean it was like not possible for her to gain weight...she was naturally thin, and always was..

 

[zanejohnson]

Some people have standards and then we have Zane Johnson. :biggrin:

shit im picky when it comes to females... but you were just being ridiculous earlier... have any pics of what your hitting by the way? or a pic of yourself?

 

[destrekor]

Nothing wrong with that size 16. The 12 looks kinda dumpy. The 8 is just an atractive woman. I think my wife is a 6 or 8, something like that.

and from what I read of an article attached to that pic, the "size 8" woman is a "U.S. size 6". we use different women clothing sizes too?
take that World and your beliefs of uniform measurements. We know we are a pain in the ass and we enjoy pissing you off! :biggrin:

Regardless, you can also tell she's typical model tall.
A size 6 or size 8 on someone 5'4" is going to look quite a bit different.

Size 1 or two on someone who is 5'2" probably looks perfect. I think someone who is 5'7" has a perfect curvature if she is, well hell if I know, probably a size 6 or 8. But in all honesty the numbers are what matters, it's all about the curves and how a woman carries weight.

 

[TallBill]

shit im picky when it comes to females... but you were just being ridiculous earlier... have any pics of what your hitting by the way? or a pic of yourself?

I would never refer to a woman that I'm seeing as "what I'm hitting".

 

[Suspicious-Teach8788]

height and build factor into it.

I'd rather have a tall and fit 8 over a sloppy and short 4.

Yes my girlfriend is short, but she's gotten a little pudge from eating out which is why she complains. there's other women i know who are taller at 5'6 or 5'7" even (Asian remember so that's definitely tall for them), and size 2 or 4. My gf's roommate is definitely smaller size (i dont have the exact # but I can inquire) than my gf, and she's 5'7".

Trust me, 8 is chubby.

8 isn't obsese or fat, but there's definitely a little fat somewhere. Now as for Beyonce she's got a little bigger build. Also being black means you have a bigger booty. That's where some of the size 8 is going. She's curvacious and she's good looking, but she's not skinny.

ATOT has a lot of people who I would consider fat. I remember that waist size poll. If you're bigger than 36, you're probably fat. TallBill is an exception because he's a body builder but we know that is not hte case for most people on ATOT.

 

[Capt Caveman]

shit im picky when it comes to females... but you were just being ridiculous earlier... have any pics of what your hitting by the way? or a pic of yourself?

I have enough respect to not post a pic of someone I'm dating in place like this. I'm not an attention whore, like some people.

 

[zanejohnson]

I have enough respect to not post a pic of someone I'm dating in place like this. I'm not an attention whore, like some people.

well how bout a pic of yourself

 

[BlahBlahYouToo]

depends on your taste, i think size 8 is just fine, 12 is on the fat side. 0 is more or less unrealistic for most people.

my gf is a 00/0/1/2

 

[zanejohnson]

I would never refer to a woman that I'm seeing as "what I'm hitting".

well im not talking about a woman i'm "seeing."

 

[TallBill]

well im not talking about a woman i'm "seeing."

Well I wouldn't be "hitting" anything that was questionably good looking.

 

[BlahBlahYouToo]

Anyone who thinks a size 8 is fat is probably the ATOT guy who makes six figures and is in perfect physical shape with an amazing social life. You're all perfect I'm sure.

yes i think size 8 is fat.
yes, i make 6 figures.
yes, i bench 1.5x bw and squat 1.8x so i'm in good (not perfect) physical shape
yes, i have an active social life

 

[zanejohnson]

Well I wouldn't be "hitting" anything that was questionably good looking.

good job then

i personally need to get laid, and right now, even though she is questionable, i think she still might pass in my book

 

[Suspicious-Teach8788]

Ok so I just talked to my girlfriend and she pointed me to one of her roommates who would be a size 8. Even if I forgot the face... no. Size 8 is too much for me. Size 0 or 2 on someone of decent height 5'6 = 5'8" is skinny... Miss Asian skinny. 4 would be fine.

I believe ATOT standards are a little rough. Just like when we talked about men and BMI and all that. People throw out excuses left and right but it's not like those excuses really apply to them. Fact is many of us are fat. I'm fat. I squeeze into my 32W jeans. Express Slim fit makes me uncomfortable. Those dress shirts I have from H&M that I used to go clubbing with make my tummy show nicely now... >< BTW I'm 5'9" and 168.

 

[zanejohnson]

Ok so I just talked to my girlfriend and she pointed me to one of her roommates who would be a size 8. Even if I forgot the face... no. Size 8 is too much for me. Size 0 or 2 on someone of decent height 5'6 = 5'8" is skinny... Miss Asian skinny. 4 would be fine.

I believe ATOT standards are a little rough. Just like when we talked about men and BMI and all that. People throw out excuses left and right but it's not like those excuses really apply to them. Fact is many of us are fat. I'm fat. I squeeze into my 32W jeans. Express Slim fit makes me uncomfortable. Those dress shirts I have from H&M that I used to go clubbing with make my tummy show nicely now... >< BTW I'm 5'9" and 168.

right, you speak the truth...

i'm 5'10 and 170... a little bit of pudge, i wouldn't consider myself a fattie though... maybe solid, but i could def. stand to lose about 10 more lbs..

by that pic she looks pretty good, i can stand about that much pudge.. just no rolls lol..

 

[hanoverphist]

Ok so I just talked to my girlfriend and she pointed me to one of her roommates who would be a size 8. Even if I forgot the face... no. Size 8 is too much for me. Size 0 or 2 on someone of decent height 5'6 = 5'8" is skinny... Miss Asian skinny. 4 would be fine.

I believe ATOT standards are a little rough. Just like when we talked about men and BMI and all that. People throw out excuses left and right but it's not like those excuses really apply to them. Fact is many of us are fat. I'm fat. I squeeze into my 32W jeans. Express Slim fit makes me uncomfortable. Those dress shirts I have from H&M that I used to go clubbing with make my tummy show nicely now... >< BTW I'm 5'9" and 168.

it may be a perspective thing then. im a huge mofo, 6'3" and a tad over 300. was in shape at about 235 and loading semis/ building stage sets, but im in round shape at the moment. ive always been large, so a 5'5" size 8 seems small and skinny to me. but i wouldnt call a size 8 woman over 5'3" fat. for that matter, i wouldnt call a size 14 woman fat either. women are evil, and hold grudges.

it might have been like a preggo pic or something, that's the only time she ever had any weight to her at all.. i mean it was like not possible for her to gain weight...she was naturally thin, and always was..

ya, could have been.

 

[surfsatwerk]

well im not talking about a woman i'm "seeing."

He's talking about the Ho's he be bangin.

 

[chalmers]

Wow...you have friends in real life zanejohnson? You seem like a total d-bag.

 

[zanejohnson]

Wow...you have friends in real life zanejohnson? You seem like a total d-bag.

why you gotta try to be a hater?

 

[jlee]

A friend of mine is a 7 and she's perfect, if not even a little on the thin side. FWIW.

 

[hanoverphist]

come to think of it, i dont think ive ever seen a size 8 while taking my daughters shopping. it was either 7 or 9, kind of like the name of that one store... "5-7-9"

 

[bob4432]

you guys all must be young, size 8 is fine except for a midget/dwarf. i like a woman w/ shape, not like a fucking boy.

 

[auntcleo]

size 8 only good if she is a midget brah