Is this overkill?

[Zuddud]

I'm about to build a new AMD X2 system and am starting to wonder if my initial thoughts on video might be a little more than what I actually need. I'll be running the native resolution of my 17" LCD of 1280x1024 in most of my games like Oblivion or BF2142.

Considering that low a resolution, is it worth it to get a hot and loud 1950xt or would I be just fine with a 1950pro? I'm basically stuck between these two:

HIS IceQ 3 Turbo X1950PRO 256MBHIS IceQ 3 Turbo X1950PRO 256MB @ $159.99 ($149 after rebate.)

SAPPHIRE X1950XT 256MB@ $179.99 ($159.99 after rebate)

I know the XT will beat the Pro in benchmarks but am I really going to notice a difference at my resolution? Considering the power and noise level differences, it seems more than a simple $10 decision.

Between those two, which way would you go?

 

[ShadowOfMyself]

Doesnt matter, the XT is much better, if you hit cpu limitation just crank up AA anyway, and you wont with new games... Even a 8800 GTX can barely pull off perfect fps with high AA

 

[Running]

yup just get the XT and when you want to play future games it will be better