Originally posted by: palehorse74
Originally posted by: Aimster
so..... when you and your buddies are pinned from gunfire coming from an apartment bulding do you
A) call for an airstrike and kill everyone in there
B) retreat back and try another day
& those buildings were not hit as a result of rocket launches. Many sites in Beiruit were hit ... there were no rocket launchers there
By the way I would call for A .. cause I am a selfish individual who values my life more than others when I am being shot at.
every single situation is different, but you might be surprised by the number of channels such a decision must go through before actions are taken. That is where JAG comes in with their role as advisers. Commanders often turn to their legal experts to assist them in such decisions.
I have first-hand experience in situations that took hours to sort out for this very reason. Yes, of course the Joes such as myself want to level the place and end the fight, but quite often we were asked to come up with alternative solutions to the problem that placed soldiers at more risk than necessary simply to prevent the death of innocent civilians.
I have taken courses in the US Army that required thorough knowledge and understanding of the Laws of Warfare. When JAG is unavailable, commanders on the ground will turn to "experts," such as myself, for advice. It is up to us to help them weigh the options and decide how much force is necessary to eliminate threats originating from sensitive targets.
Another example occurs during mission planning. One of the most important pieces of information for the ground-pounders is a description of civilians in the area of a target. That information is used to decide the best possible course of action; one that limits the number of civilians exposed to danger. (Time of day, foot traffic, religious or historic buildings, etc).
The irony is that all of our enemies know all of this and exploit it as a weakness. They
know that staging their operations next to schools or mosques will limit our response capabilities, so they use those locations against us! This is a SOP for insurgents and terrorists everywhere, including Hezbollah!
That's the reality of modern combat, and the Israeli's operate in a very similar fashion. Believing otherwise is just plain ignorant.
Once again, go study the Laws of Warfare instead of assuming that you know
anything about modern combat.