The people of Gaza are oppressed by circumstances created by multiple nation states in the region INCLUDING ISRAEL!...And Egypt and Lebanon, they’ve certainly helped bottle up Gaza and they like having Gaza as a thorn in Israel's side. When Israel was giving the Sinai back to Egypt back in the 1970’s they offered to throw in Gaza as part of the deal. The Egyptians didn’t want it. Hamas and other terrorist organizations do not want Palestinians to leave Gaza. They want them to be victims. The main point of many players in the mid-east is to wipe Israel off the face of the earth. Moving Palestinians or even helping them does not play into this long-game for them.
Hamas knows this and intentionally behaves in such a way that these sorts of measures are seen as necessary. Even this attack is calculated specifically to be as heinous as possible and ensure that Israel responds. That’s been Hamas SOP since 2007 when they took power. Unlike Fatah who are in power in the West Bank, they have absolutely no interest in negotiating a way forward. Palestinian suffering directly benefits Hamas so long as they can keep anger directed at Israel rather than themselves. The whole point of the attacks on music festival goers, children and other civilians was to provoke a huge response and get lots of Palestinian civilians killed. The leaders of Hamas and those that enable them don’t give a shit about their own civilians; they want full and complete control over the territory.
These circumstances have created a breeding ground for hate-filled militants. Hamas has never had ANY incentive to support economic development, since that would cut into their recruiting. Things like travel restrictions only make those circumstances worse. Israel has leveled the place. Israel must take the - you broke it ... you bought it approach. They were the ones who helped create the Gaza Strip festering pot of rage and suffering to begin with, so once they wipe out Hamas, they should fucking fix the place, what was termed the world’s largest open-air prison.
It helps that Hamas leader...what's-his-name, is bravely leading from fucking Qatar. lol. So it’s not like HE has personal stake in the matter. At least until he suffers a tragic fall out a window, or he is hit by a “stray bullet” fired from a yacht a mile out to sea. Being in Qatar will not shield this guy from Israel.
Israel has had a policy of containment, hoping Hamas will burn out or mellow over time. Clearly that hasn’t happened, and Hamas has proven they cannot be contained. And, containment imposes its own cost, embittering the lives of Palestinians and ensuring they stick with Hamas.
At this point de-escalation with Hamas is impossible. They are most likely going to be destroyed as we know it today. But once that’s done, and Fatah who runs the West Bank or someone else is put in charge, Israel must ... A, protect them from a resurgent Hamas or whatever other extremist groups pop up, with military force if necessary, and B, ensure they’re actually able to improve the lives of Gazans who are still left or decide to come back, so they have something to lose by going back to Hamas.
But, the sad reality is, I think it’s absurd to suggest that Palestinians could realistically attain a non -“sucky” degree of rights and freedom if only they’d get rid of Hamas. The Israeli government has made it very clear that they have no interest in that potential future, and in fact have expansionist objectives that directly conflict with it. But it's their only real option to try get out from under Hamas and those enablers, There is no other way forward and the world should hold Israel accountable.