It's official, she's a her

[rasczak]

No, but being born with testicles and no ovaries DOES make you a man.

but what about her vag? there's the difference right there, if she has a vag, and undescended testicles, that would make her more of a woman than a man.

 

[IGBT]

she's a man among womenz.

 

[olds]

"It's official, she's a her"

I thought you finally gave up on Lady Gaga.

 

[Blackjack200]

"It's official, she's a her"

I thought you finally gave up on Lady Gaga.

Ugh, I was just about to make this joke. Can I have credit for it?

 

[moshquerade]

I believe she is trying to point out that many women can't concieve a child for various reasons, yet this doesn't not disqualify them from being a women.

Exactly, SandEagle was just trolling me as usual. He knew what I meant. I have him/it on ignore, but he/it gets quoted and then unfortunately I see his paltry attempts to flamebait me.

 

[ModestGamer]

You don't realize how many women you just put a knife thru.

they aren't terriably useful unless they wet nurse or provide child care. Hence why they are often relegated to subserviant roles as omega females in the most cultures.

 

[AndroidVageta]

I feel that if you are NOT born PURE female you shouldnt be able to compete as one. If anything just because you may TECHNICALLY be a "female" you are still on quite a manly frame and build, as is obvious by her pictures.

If I were born with a vagina and testicles but no ovaries I can compete as a female? What if I wanted to compete as a male?

Lines have to be drawn somewhere...and this is one of those times. Im sorry, but its just an unfair advantage...and not so much unfair just because shes better and faster, but just because she shouldnt be competing with real 100% females like all the other participants are.

I may not be 100% politically correct here, but I dont care...you just have to say no to people sometimes...doesnt matter what gender they are or lack-there-of...

 

[Dumac]

So....if you were a 'male' without testicals...are you allowed to compete in male sports?

Or for those who think this female runner shouldn't be allow to compete in women's sports, can she compete in the male division?

Is the general consensus on this board that men are better than women, and that being a woman is a disadvantage?

 

[Keeper]

I will if you agree to grow a brain. Deal?

Whatever you say OH Superior one...


Good day.....

 

[Dumac]

Whatever you say OH Superior one...


Good day.....

Oh man. You're a pretty smart jellyfish.

 

[Drako]

Is the general consensus on this board that men are better than women, and that being a woman is a disadvantage?

Look at the time differences between men's and women's track, and you have your answer.

http://www.trackandfieldnews.com/tfn/records/records.jsp?listId=1

http://www.trackandfieldnews.com/tfn/records/records.jsp?sex=W&typeId=0&listId=2

 

[dank69]

...Is the general consensus on this board that men are better than women, and that being a woman is a disadvantage?

What a silly question. Women are for making sammiches.

 

[Dumac]

Look at the time differences between men's and women's track, and you have your answer.

So since women are inferior (in sports) any trace of manliness is a potentially unfair advantage?

How far do we go, because gender lines can be pretty easily blurred.

Do the female reproductive organs have to be in pristine condition? Should we start checking all women to make sure they have fertile ovaries?

 

[Keeper]

Oh man. You're a pretty smart jellyfish.

?

I dont get it.. Better to leave him alone? Is he always this antagonistic?

Or by the fact you called me jelly fish you too are jumping in and calling me spineless.

I am getting a mixed message.

But I get that a lot LOL.....

Flame wars..... When I was 15... Maybe LOL... Big maybe...

Internet tends to strip people's manners away...
I made a point, and had one fact incorrect. Still doesnt deter from my position that he (the golfer guy I was speaking about) NOR this person should be allowed to compete.
And right off the bat zippy refers to talking out the asshole?
Nah, that speaks levels to this person........ Done move on...
Life's too short to deal with mouth breathers.

 

[Drako]

So since women are inferior (in sports) any trace of manliness is a potentially unfair advantage?

How far do we go, because gender lines can be pretty easily blurred.

Do the female reproductive organs have to be in pristine condition? Should we start checking all women to make sure they have fertile ovaries?

I guess that should be up to each sports governing body what actually comprises being a "female". I would think that if you were a female athlete, that you would want a fair playing field. Otherwise gender based sport might as well go away.

 

[amdhunter]

so since women are inferior (in sports) any trace of manliness is a potentially unfair advantage?

How far do we go, because gender lines can be pretty easily blurred.

Do the female reproductive organs have to be in pristine condition? Should we start checking all women to make sure they have fertile ovaries?

HOLY SHIT PEOPLE. He has TESTICLES! THATS IT, END OF STORY. THAT IS NOT A WOMAN.

 

[Dumac]

?

I dont get it.. Better to leave him alone? Is he always this antagonistic?

Or by the fact you called me jelly fish you too are jumping in and calling me spineless.

I am getting a mixed message.

But I get that a lot LOL.....

Flame wars..... When I was 15... Maybe LOL... Big maybe...

Internet tends to strip people's manners away...
I made a point, and had one fact incorrect. Still doesnt deter from my position that he NOR this person should be allowed to compete.
And right off the bat zippy refers to talking out the asshole?
Nah, that speaks levels to this person........ Done move on...
Life's too short to deal with mouth breathers.

Haha

He called you brainless, so I making the joke that I took his comment literally by saying that you are pretty smart for someone without a brain.

I mean, if you really had no brain, then posting on ATOT would be quite a feat.

 

[Dumac]

HOLY SHIT PEOPLE. He has TESTICLES! THATS IT, END OF STORY. THAT IS NOT A WOMAN.

What if someone has testicles, but no penis?

Or someone had fully functioning ovaries, but also a penis?

Is the slightest trait of male genitalia taint the person's gender? Or is it that being male is so much better than being female, thats only the purest females can be counted as female, for the sake of their protection?

 

[spaceman]

Vinny Testiclverde

 

[amdhunter]

What if someone has testicles, but no penis? Man.

Or someone had fully functioning ovaries, but also a penis? Woman.

Is the slightest trait of male genitalia taint the person's gender? Or is it that being male is so much better than being female, thats only the purest females can be counted as female, for the sake of their protection?

Simple Test:
Testicles? Man
Ovaries? Woman

 

[Drako]

Or is it that being male is so much better than being female, thats only the purest females can be counted as female, for the sake of their protection?

So are you advocating no gender based sports? I'm not really sure what your point is.

 

[a123456]

Another article said something about her getting treatment for the high testosterone. If there's some medical way to get her hormone levels to within the normal range, there should be no problems competing on a level playing field. However, with the reduced hormones, she might not be a world champion runner anymore.

She could easily get the vestigial testicles removed. Then, what's the next excuse? Anyway, IAAF has already made their decision.

 

[Dumac]

So are you advocating no gender based sports? I'm not really sure what your point is.

I don't really have one. My posts are just a lame attempt to inject some life into an otherwise stale debate by shifting the topic to gender roles in general.

 

[kami333]

Do the female reproductive organs have to be in pristine condition? Should we start checking all women to make sure they have fertile ovaries?

Wouldn't work since many high-performance female athletes usually aren't fertile, they have no periods or irregular periods.

Evolutionarily it was advantageous to not breed during periods of intense exercise since it usually meant it was a bad time to have babies.

 

[Dumac]

Simple Test:
Testicles? Man
Ovaries? Woman

So, in this hypothetical world, if it turned Arnold Schwarzenegger actually had functioning ovaries hidden inside him, he would be a woman?

And it turned out Megan Fox actually had testicles inside her? She would be a man (and all of you guys on ATOT would be gay)?

EDIT: or what if someone had both testicles and ovaries?