Could you point to statistics that show that voter fraud is probable and that voter ID laws will significantly prevent cases of voter fraud from occurring without disenfranchising anyone who is legally allowed to vote?
Personally, I'm OK with these risks. To me, it is similar to our justice system, where we allow guilty people to occasionally go free just so we can avoid locking up innocent people. If legal citizens are prevented from voting under the auspices of this law, then in my mind, it is an abject failure and an affront to everything I hold dear about American democracy. We don't need laws based around the fear that something terrible might happen. What are the actual stats on voter fraud? I've seen numbers that say there have been less than 100 cases in Pennsylvania in the last 5 years. 6,000,000 Pennsylvanians voted in the 2008 Presidential election. Even if all 100 cases of voter fraud occurred in that year, that's less than 0.002% of the vote. Is 0.002% of the vote really going to sway the election? Could cutting hundreds of thousands of names from voter rolls potentially do a lot more to sway the elections?
This is an unnecessary law to address a problem that does not exist. It disenfranchises legal voters for absolutely no reason, or at least not the stated reason. There is not a big wave of illegal immigrants in Pennsylvania committing voter fraud every year. Yes, it happens, but it is nowhere near as big a problem as you make it out to be, and all this law does is make things worse. Disenfranchising any legal voters for any reason is unAmerican and every true patriot in this country should be against it.