I actually hate Depp in all his movies. I used to merely be indifferent but Pirates put me over the edge. cannot fvcking watch a movie with him. his acting style is always the same: act like somebody with mental problems. Doesn't matter the movie, I just find it insufferable to watch. Those movies were ruined by him.
And regarding that remake of chocolate factory, unwatchable sh*t and tripe. In fact, he wasn't the main problem with that. The darkness of it was. They took a good movie and made it crap and then he just happened to be the icing on that crap cake. He is one of the main reasons I will never watch the Alice in wonderland, a truly aggravating person to watch on screen. One dimensional like no other actor is.