Been on a horror movie kick with my gf. All ratings are based on the type of movie it tries to be. So if it tries to be a suspense movie, but fails and ends up with cheap gore, then I'd give it a lower rating, and I'll explain why in my description.
Slaughter - 5.5/10 Basically a saw rip off where a killer locks a bunch of rich kids in a house and makes them choose who dies next. Wasn't awful, acting wasn't horrid, wasn't great. Some good shock moments, some great gore. One nice thing: There wasn't anyone even vaguely famous and it didn't focus on any one character so you didn't really know who was going to survive. If you want some cheap gore, decent suspense, check it out.[/b]
The Orphanage (El Orfanato) - 6.5/10 Spanish horror/suspense flick about an orphanage. Had REALLY high expectations for this one. Didn't QUITE meet them, but there's a great twist. Also had the best sub-titles of all time. I don't know WHO subtitled it, but they need to be shot. There'd be whole scenes where subtitles didn't appear, other times it looked like the subtitles were in Engrish, and once there was even a "???????????" for a subtitle, even though the person was speaking clearly, and I even could translate a few words. It didn't ruin the movie, but probably lowered the rating a bit. Worth a watch I'd say. Some scary/shock scenes, and does a decent, though not perfect job of building suspense. If you like horror movies involving kids, you'll like this one.
The Reflecting Skin - 5.5/10 Still don't know WHAT to think of this one. I liked it somewhat, gf hated it. Stars Lena Headley from Terminator: S.C. Chronicles. The suspense in this one is psychological. Not really much gore, so if you want a gore/shock fest, this isn't going to be your movie at all. If you like psychological terror (and really some scenes were really terrifying), go for it. Great twist at the end, although some will probably see it coming.
Dead Snow 8.5/10 Nazi Zombies attacking a group of med students on break in a remote section of the woods. I give it an 8.5 because for what it tries to be, it does great. Don't go into this one expecting masterful suspense and psychological terror. It's gore, startling moments, shocking moments, and a good fun time. If you want some good shock-gore horror, and some funny scenes, I'd go for this one. Again, if you're not pretentious, and you also like some good shock scenes, and things of that ilk, check this out.
Slaughter - 4/10 Girl leaves her boyfriend, goes to Atlanta (?), meets a friend, ends up involved in this serial killing plot taking place on a farm. It's hard to explain without giving it away. The movie just didn't do it for me. It's like they tried to cram too many subplots in, child molesting, slaughtering animals, psycho parents, slutty friends. It SOUNDS good, and after watching it I felt like it should've been good. There's a somewhat decent twist that saves this from being complete crap. It wasn't really extreme gore...wasn't extreme shock...wasn't a psychological thriller...wasn't suspenseful. Just didn't do it for me.
Fear Itself (Season 1) -10/10 Great show on NBC. Each week a different person directs an episode. It's not a series; each episode is a standalone 42 minute horror show. Even if you don't like one week's, there's always the next. There's a vampire one, a witch one, a werewolf one, psychological terror in a few episodes. It's really great. Of course it got canned after 7 episodes or so on NBC. You can find all 14 that were made online. Ironically I think the best ones were later in the season. Really good series. Not sure how long it could've lasted before they ran out of ideas, but it really was like an adult version of Are you Afraid of the Dark
Mr. Boogedy Two: Bride of Boogedy 8/10 My gf told me about this horror movie she saw as a kid that scared the crap out of her. To surprise her I found it and we watched it one night. (Brownie points for me ). It's not bad for a kid's first horror/terror/scary movie. Nothing too violent, but scary enough that kids (1st or 2nd grade or so) should get a good scare out of it. If you got kids, give it a shot